Graniteville residents lose water fight at PSC

  • Follow Metro

COLUMBIA --- Graniteville residents who won relief last week from spiking water and sewer bills are back to Square One.

Treye Sharpe holds up a copy of his last month's water bill in comparison to the current month on Wednesday, August 5, 2009.  Jackie Ricciardi/Staff
Jackie Ricciardi/Staff
Treye Sharpe holds up a copy of his last month's water bill in comparison to the current month on Wednesday, August 5, 2009.

The South Carolina Public Service Commission voted Wednesday to reinstate Avondale Mills' higher rates.

The rates, which the commission approved in June, provoked outrage among residents, whose bills were seven or eight times higher than before.

"It's wrong," Rep. Roland Smith, R-Warrenville, a retired minister, told commissioners Wednesday.

"It may be legal ... But in God's eyes, it's wrong. People have been taken advantage of."

Mr. Smith was joined by state Rep. Tom Young, R-Aiken, and state Sen. Shane Massey, R-Edgefield, who all faulted Avondale Mills for not proposing its own compromise when the company rejected their ideas.

But Scott Elliott, the company's attorney, defended the water provider before the commission.

He said the company participated in phone calls and meetings with rate-increase opponents, and "considered each and every proposal."

Avondale officials have said the rate increases were necessary to allow the company to break even, because mill closures had forced them to subsidize the water system.

Commissioner Randy Mitchell said he was aware of residents' struggles, but offered the motion to reinstate the higher rates.

"I know what it is like to work for a living, and I understand the problems that are in that particular community," said Mr. Mitchell, who represents Aiken, Edgefield and eight other counties.

Six community residents attended the Wednesday meeting, including Linda and Ken Hodges of Vaucluse, whose monthly bill jumped from $5.05 to $69 as a result of the increase.

"We have a lot of pipe breakages," said Mrs. Hodges, who had collected complaints from more than a dozen residents.

"But these are all old mill workers that are retired. They have no way of doing anything (to fix them.)"

Mrs. Hodges said she's gone through four hot water tanks in one year and suspects it's because of sand in the water lines.

After the vote, Mr. Young vowed to continue looking for a way to help residents of the community.

"The bottom line is we're going to keep fighting for them, and we're going to find a way to fix this problem," he said.

The next PSC meeting is scheduled for Oct. 6.

"That is too long away," said Mr. Massey.

Graniteville resident Treye Sharpe, who helped organize a community meeting in opposition to the new water and sewer rates, said Wednesday that he hopes to pay his bill, which is due Saturday.

He said he's disappointed with the PSC decision, which raised his monthly assessment from an average of $72 to $597.

Reach Sarita Chourey at (803) 727-4257 or sarita.chourey@morris.com.

RELATED STORIES

Residents shocked over bills


Graniteville water negotiations continue


Agency to evaluate new rates


Residents air anger over water bills


Water customers head to Columbia for PSC meeting

Here's a look at how 53,000 gallons could be used:

33,125

Flushes using a new low-flow toilet at 1.6 gallons per flush

1,325

Loads of laundry at 40 gallons a load

2,650

10-minute showers at 2 gallons per minute

53,000

Tooth-brushings, at 1 gallon each

Source: U.S. Geological Survey

THE RULING: The South Carolina Public Service Commission voted Wednesday to reinstate Avondale Mills' adjusted water and sewer rates, which made some Graniteville residents' bills seven or eight times higher.

THE RATE: Graniteville residents who paid a subsidized 51 cents per 1,000 gallons for water will pay $4.50 per 1,000 gallons. For sewer treatment, they will pay $6.50 per 1,000 gallons, an increase from 89 cents per 1,000 gallons.

Comments

Asitisinaug

An all house water filter outsid your house is a heck of a lot cheaper than 4 hot water heaters. By now, you could have had a well dug and done away with the Avondale water. This must be tough on the citizens and it is a sad situation. On the other hand, you can't expect a private business to loose money. If they are simply "breaking even" as shown to the commission, then they are doing the community a favor as it is now. If ANYONE in that communtiy owned the water system and was loosing money they would simply want to sell it or close it down. Time to conserve and from the rates they have been paying for the last 28 years, they have been saving a fortune.

bettyboop

I am baffled at the amount of water used...I watered my lawn everyday from 6/29-7/31...and do at least 1 to 2 loads of laundry per day not to mention showers for 3 people and dishwasher and so on ..my gallons used were 5900......what are these folks doing with all that water? Bill 29.00 to the city of North Auguista..I do not pay sewer fees.

wizzardx1

avondale has the water that everyone needs-they can charge any amount for it that they want.try living without water is what avondale is telling residents

wizzardx1

the well-drilling business should be booming

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

damemarystuart... we are not using that much water! No one from Avondale comes to read our meters. There are 4 people in my house. Before this, I was charged for an average of 7000 per month in the winter and about 15000 in the summer when we water our grass. This time, I was charged for 48000 gallons! Does that make sense? We didn't do anything different last month. Avondale is a corrupt corporation trying to put one over on us. That is one of the reasons people are so mad. We know we were getting water cheap, we know we were due a increase, but why should our rate be $4.50 when other communities around us are paying $1.50 - $1.79? This is the issue.

getalife

Sounds like Avondale may be falsifying the amount of water used or the meters are wrong??

Little Lamb

Look at this quote from Linda Hodges: "But these are all old mill workers that are retired. They have no way of doing anything (to fix them.)" Well, Mrs. Hodges sounds like a bigot who thinks that senior citizens are helpless. I'll have you know that many senior citizens lead productive lives and take care of their property.

aftbrn

If I were those residents, my first call would be to well drilling company and a good water filtration system. Easily paying for itself in the first 6 moths if their bills really were going to be $550 a month or higher. I think if I lived there I would do it anyway ASAP just despite that water company for being such theives. Nothing would give me more pleasure than to call them and say get your meter out of here.

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

Well I'm not old or retired, I'm 31 and I have 2 small children. Both my spouse and myself work. getalife... you are correct. most of the meters don't work, I guess that is why they dont read them. aftbrn... yes people are looking into putting in wells, we will also have to put in septic tanks. It's going to cost alot of money to do this. Someone on my street was looking into seeing if we all go with the same company to install these if we would get a better deal. This is not right... and I don't believe it's even close to being over with.

Carefree

Before i can put in a well or septic tank avondale needs to come get the sewer cap and sewer that takes up half my yard since that is how big most of the yards here are and dig it up like they were going to do a few months ago when they came and marked it all then realized they would probably have to take the tree out and my carport?To much work i quess especially when they aren't use to doing any.

Carefree

I can guarantee they misquoted Mrs. Hodges in that story!What she was most likely referring to was the pipe breaks in the system itself that avondale doesn't fix. Look people i have a fire hydrant behind my house i had to beg avondale for two weeks to come fix it while it leaked out into a main road for everyone to enjoy a natural spring!I had to call 12 on your side just to get them out here to fix the stupid thing before it flooded my yard!This is what Avondale calls good business!

Carefree

Alright everybody i'm staying off of here you have at it I think the above information speaks for itself there's absolutely no way according to the US GEOLOGICAL SURVEY that the water readings in Graniteville can be correct and if anyone believes that they are then you're leaving out all logic. Thanks for finally posting some useful information Augusta Chronicle.

Little Lamb

Hey, Graniteville Resident, I got a chuckle out of that U.S. Geological Survey chart up above, too. Unfortunately, they left out two BIG contributors to wasted water. If a person has a leaky flapper valve in his toilet(s), he can easily go through 53,000 gallons in a month. Likewise, if a person waters his lawn and garden too much, he can easily rack up 53,000 gallons in a month.

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

I'm surprised water came out of the fire hydrant. Most of the hydrants in Graniteville do not work.

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

so Little Lamb, do you honetly think everyone in Graniteville has a leaky toilet? We water 3 days a week and have no leaks! 48000 like my bill said is not possible!

purmkinhed

Avondale are a bunch of crooks and they have now padded the pockets of The South Carolina Public Service Commission so they would sway in their favor! Like I said the other day, those meters and pipework are ANTIQUATED and need to be replaced. Of course Avondale will not do it because they are crying poverty. I do not water my lawn but I do have a leaky water hose and I used 7000 gallons of water this past month. Little Lamb, if you think a flapper problem on a toilet will make someones water usage rise to 53,000 gallons your a freaking idiot!

Carefree

Little Lamb i'd hate to think the intelligence of The Ode is rubbing off on you. Your comments didn't bother me till i saw that you are probably like most others on here out to make fun of what most of you refer to as "the valley." One minute you're telling us to seek God then next you're making fun. I'm disappointed.

Carefree

If no one thinks these companies are pocket padding go back and research the proposed 2005 TIF bill. There's been pocket padding going on for a while now where Graniteville is concerned.

daddyfrog1

What type of government does Graniteville have ? Can the city incorporate and buy the water system from this private firm ?If these water pipes are broken, meters not working, and fire hydrants inoperative or leaking there have to be county and/or environmental laws being broken.The good people of Graniteville should contact the governor's office about all of this if they haven't done so already.You could also contact "20/20" and "60 Minutes", and get your plight national attention.And don't forget our Senators & Congressmen are home.Give them an earfull at one of their townhall meetings !

Little Lamb

DaddyFrog is giving good advice. The customers of the Avondale water system can complain to DHEC about poor quality of water and inaccurate meters (they'd better be able to show some evidence) and Avondale could be ordered by DHEC to fix the leaky pipes. Likewise, the residents of Graniteville/Vaucluse could complain to the state insurance commissioner that the fire hydrants don't work and they will be ordered by him to fix the fire hydrants. That'll show 'em.

Little Lamb

You know, I think it is kind of sad that only six residents of Graniteville/Vaucluse made the 45-mile trip to Columbia to show solidarity against the new rates. No wonder the PSC left the rates if no more than six bothered to go.

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

I was at work. Thank you.

imdstuf

Asitisinaug, you meant "losing" not "loosing." Its okay for government to break their own laws and shut down a business like X-Mart that actually generated tax revenue, in a spot otherwise left for dead, but the government cannot find any ways around helping individual tax payers not be extorted at the will of a greedy corporation who already shut down and took away their jobs.

Carefree

Thanks DaddyFrog as most of us are getting our first good taste of what Corporate greed and sneakiness can really do we haven't had a lot of experience with who can help. I'll take your advice and Little Lamb DHEC is another good option but seeing what side of the payroll DHEC has been on around here that may not be easy. They love Wyatt Development and Avondale and the show themselves occasionally around here to put up new do not enter asbestos signs.

bettyboop

Please...I was not making fun...my observation was there can not be that much water used in one month..I believe you have been taken advantage of and it looks like you are going to need legal help...I would hope someone in the legal profession would gather you all together and plan a defense....good luck!

Carefree

One last thought if we had incorporated we would have probably have seen the highest ticketed price for a water company given in history. Felker is not going to give up that company without a big price he's way to greedy and besides he has to listen to the real man with the plan and that's not him. Also if we had incorporated you would see us footing the bill for most of these new developments which is what Wyatt Development and Fine Deering was hoping for when they tried to force the 2005 TIF bill on the residents of Graniteville. Most of Graniteville is now made up of multimillion dollar subdivisions if most of you would look up the above named companies you may find it interesting that this whole issue is only over around 600 residences that sit in the middle of prime business real estate for Wyatt Development and Fine Deering. I don't what else to do to make you get this point this is a corporate move to push us out.

curly123053

They tried to incorporate recently and the referendum failed. Incorporation would save a lot of grief and whining regarding this subject. It looks to me like the people of Graniteville need to start using their water a little more wisely. It is time to practice water conservation like we do at our home. In the meantime the local state reps can work on getting a public provider to take over that system so it can be updated and made more efficient.

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

graniteville resident - your last post is right on the money! curly - how can you be so ignorant? Have you read any of the above posts?

ProudToBeFromGraniteville

I voted no to incorporation because of the exact reason that graniteville resident stated above. They wanted US to pay for the new development because we'd get such a "better quality of life" if all these "new and improved" things came to our town. Sorry, but I love Graniteville because it is not run over with fast food restaurants, pay-day loan shops, etc. We wanted our HOMETOWN (I don't think some of you know the real meaning of the word) to stay the wonderful, Christian, family-oriented town it is.

Yellow House

That is exactly why we moved here 3 yrs ago from South Aiken and bought a house Proud to be from Gvills. We wanted away from all that mess. My husband works for KimClark...he works extremely hard and works alot of OT and makes really good money to provide for his family contrary to what some posts are saying about valley people. We could have moved anywhere. ANYWHERE. We looked at homes in many upper end subdivisions in Aiken and we chose a 150 yr old home in Gville with history and we have put alot of work and money into it. There is no way we would leave nor would anyone push us out. This community has such a tight bond, like no other we have seen since moving south 13 years ago. I may not be from the valley originally, but we are PROUD to be from the valley now.

And, what some of you are refusing to read...the usage is WRONG. Ours was 21000. We are watching the meter close..and as of right now we are only at 5000. We are NOT going to reach 21000 in no way shape or form. We only have maybe another 2 weeks before the so called next reading. I estimate we will be at 9000. And yes, we did water 2 times before rain AND topped pool off. We have changed nothing. Do the math.

Top headlines

Complex is trouble for police

On Sunday, deputies found the body of Truemaine Jones, 27, in the parking lot. It was the third homicide in the 192-unit complex since May.
Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.
Loading...