America's grim reality

  • Follow Editorials

Eight percent of registered Augusta voters turned out recently to vote on the special-purpose local option sales tax that will help chart the future of the city's civic and economic infrastructure.

Reality TV stars Jon Gosselin (right) and his wife, Kate Gosselin.  Associated Press
Associated Press
Reality TV stars Jon Gosselin (right) and his wife, Kate Gosselin.

But have you heard the big news? Jon and Kate are getting a divorce!

Snag 10 people off the Augusta streets at any given time, and it's likely you'll get more people who can give you the latest update of the reality show Jon & Kate Plus 8 than people who could tell you what hinged on the SPLOST vote.

That speaks volumes. Sad, sad volumes.

Pennsylvania couple Jon and Kate Gosselin, parents to sextuplets and twins, agreed about two years ago to have their lives placed under the reality-show microscope to show the unconventional family's ups and downs.

A cute concept, perhaps - but, in the end, poorly executed. The show portrayed the family warts and all, alright, showing the increasingly fractious relationship between the shouting, demanding Kate and the sheepish, hapless Jon.

More than 10 million people tuned in to the show's most recent episode, in which the Gosselins announced that they were separating.

Did the pressure cooker of being on a reality show lead to the split? Are these eight innocent children being exploited, and their privacy being sacrificed, by their parents for financial gain?

Those questions are being debated still. But the bottom line is that it's wrong for so many Americans to obsess over this. In a way, reality shows are training a camera on America's decline.

All this arguably started with a grandfather of the modern reality show, An American Family, the famously controversial 1973 PBS documentary that followed a year in the life of the Loud family of Santa Barbara, Calif. The 12-hour program cast an unblinking eye upon the Louds' crumbling marriage and the emerging homosexuality of one of their sons, Lance.

Back then, it was groundbreaking, compelling viewing. Today, amid the glut of reality television shows, we instead are subjected to such programs as Brooke Knows Best, which follows the day-to-day banalities of the 21-year-old daughter of former professional wrestler "Hulk" Hogan.

Reality shows lay bare the difference between fame and celebrity. Fame is earned. Celebrity is vapid. It's increasingly becoming the booby prize a person gets for stumbling, intentionally or not, into the media spotlight.

So, yes, the Gosselins are celebrities - and they're paying the price.

And so are TV viewers.

That's because reality television basically is voyeurism, and voyeurism is unhealthy both for the ones being watched and the people who are watching. Maybe the Gosselins would've divorced anyway had they not been under the unblinking eyes of television cameras. But those cameras certainly haven't made their lives easier.

And the show itself hasn't made anyone's lives any better - unless you count the people profiting from it.

Don't think divorce will kill this cash cow. Episodes still are being filmed, and new broadcasts will resume in August after a short summer hiatus.

"How does the show go on?" Kate Gosselin asked. "The show must go on."

Must it really?

Comments

patriciathomas

What is less real than reality shows? What is less entertaining than this type of "entertainment"? As a conservative, I admit to not understanding the attraction. None of the people I associate with will admit to ever sitting through an entire reality show episode. While I have tried to see what these shows offer, by the first commercial I've forgotten the tv is even on. None of them have been interesting enough to even be boring. I know someone watches them, otherwise there wouldn't be so many of them that have run more than one season. Do you think there is an emotional and mental divide between fans of these shows and people with a life?

imdstuf

Grouping all reality shows together is like grouping all dramas or all sitcoms together. I find a few reality shows entertaining, just like I find a few other types of shows entertaining (though nothing tops watching Baseball or Football games!!). Many of the reality shows are not pure reality, as you can tell there are parts highly staged, setup, etc. Still, I do not consider them reality, at least not the ones I watch on VH1. They are just silly entertainment to me, and funnier than many sitcoms.

ONLY THE TRUTH

PT, Some may ask the same question (your last line) to the regular posters here. Perhaps a little understanding and, God forbid from you, a little tolerance for those different than you.

Riverman1

Editors, that should be "anyone's LIFE any better." But the reality concept is more immediate and relevant to people than much of television. I always found biographies describing the person's thoughts in day to day life more revealing for many of the same reasons that reality shows work.

HotFoot

Leave it to PT to bring conservatives into what is essentially an apolitical issue. Yeah, most of these shows are worthless, just as most of the dramas and sitcoms are worthless, but there are good representatives of the genre. "So You Think You Can Dance" is a reality show, much as the icky "American Idol" is, but it is truly based on talent and hard work and is inspiring to watch. "Project Runway" is very entertaining. There are others. Eventually, the craze will die off. The bottom line, as always, is if you don't like it, don't watch.

HotFoot

Exactly, southernguy. However, you can't blame people for criticizing their opinions (Rush & O'Reilly), especially when they have acolytes who repeat their scripture, chapter and verse, ad nauseum.

omnomnom

TV does not care about you or what happens to you. It's downright bad for your health now, and that's not a far-out concept. I think watching the TV is bad for you. It is bad for your physical health and your mental health. - Tom Petty

JohnQPublic

People watch these shows to forget about their own problems. I just don't find it interesting at all. I never watched it, never did, never will, and I vote everytime. But that doesn't make me any "better" than the next person. Freedom, gives us the choice. And, that's why it is our responsibility to vote.

dashiel

This is a confession. I don't wear my helmet when I watch Jon and Kate.

patriciathomas

only the truth, a tolerance for reality shows? What?

wizzardx1

The ONLY true "reality"show would be one in which the participants are unaware of the cameras.

ColdBeerBoiledPeanuts

But those are pay per view!

mad_max

I guess I just don't get it with any of the "reality" shows. They are no more reality than TV "wrestling". Every situation is scripted and probably rehearsed. Most of the "plots" are the same and the only question is on which island or swamp will it be filmed. Apparently these programs provide some kind of entertainment, engrossing attachment, or something to a large number of people. Probably the same audience that gets their political instructions from the same mainstearm networks. In both cases their drival does nothing for me.

augnewsgirl09

I am so guilty of watching reality shows.

ladyjanegrey

Now THIS is enlighting conversation for the Editorial page......LOL..methinks the Chronicle is a bit stagestruck these days.................someone new there a TMZ wannabe?

Grasshopper

ladyjanegrey LMAO!

Grasshopper

Hey now I like Dirty Jobs, and Deadliest Catch. I can't stand the Pop cultured fantasy land of TV reality shows. The weather channel hasn't created theirs yet, have they?

jack

Exactly, southernguy. However, you can't blame people for criticizing their opinions (Rush & O'Reilly), especially when they have acolytes who repeat their scripture, chapter and verse, ad nauseum.
Posted by HotFoot on Tue Jun 30, 2009 6:21 AM....the fact that there are those of us on here who share Rush's, O;Reily's and Hannity's opinions doesn't mean we are regurgitating them. We just see politics through the same prism-conservatism. As for O'Reilly, he is about as fair and balanced a program as they come. Hell, he even gets Barney Frank to come on and debate him.

jack

Bottom line on TV is that about the only thing worth watching these days is college football and good old movie re-runs. Most everything else is a re-run of a re-run.

lowellbrown

"Fame is earned. Celebrity is vapid." That's good. Referring to another popular current topic, I'd say James Brown represents fame, while Michael Jackson represents celebrity. The Godfather was heavy on art while the King of Pop was heavy on crap. To get back to the subject of TV, can producers really be sure that most people just want to watch crap? I have some doubts about that.

ONLY THE TRUTH

PT..No Jackazz a tolerance for people who like entertainment that you don't.

patriciathomas

Was that a tolerant response, only the truth?

ITsDoc

TV that draws no audience does not last. While I don't watch "reality" TV, enough obviously do to make it profitable. I exercise my liberal side: If I don't like it, I don't watch it.

patriciathomas

I couldn't agree more, ItsDoc. I think what has all the "fans" panties in a bunch is my closing sentence @ 11:24pm. I don't think it was politically correct.

Taylor B

This is not reality TV. As I look in my life, I don't see eight kids, record contracts, my dad isn't a pro wrestler, i don't have twenty five women to pick a wife from (at the same time, at least...), and I don't live on an island. In real life there are no immunity challenges, second chances, commercial breaks or editing. I would be willing to bet the cars in my driveway more people voted for their american idol in Augusta than the SPLOST. What can you do.... the cattle needs that salt lick as a distraction.

ONLY THE TRUTH

You r good PT

Top headlines

Michaux: Tiger-Phil duel whets Masters appetite

For all the intrigue generated by some fresh faces in golf the last couple of years, nothing injects life into a season like an old-fashioned Tiger-Phil duel.
Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.
Loading...