| YEAR | HORSE | OWNER | RIDER |
| 2008 | High Brow CD (222) | Arthur Noble | Austin Shepard |
| 2007 | My Guy Rey (220) | Charles Burger | Phil Rapp |
| 2006 | Pet Squirrel (220) | James Vangilder | Roger Wagner |
| 2005 | Play Stocks (224) | Slate River Ranch | Michelle Hall |
| 2004 | Aristo Katz (224.5) | Jack and Susan Waggoner | Clint Allen |
| 2003 | Chiquita Pistol (230.5) | Wallace Dorman | Tag Rice |
| 2002 | Dulces Smart Lena (223) | Dulces Smart Lena Syndicate | Phil Rapp |
| 2001 | Pretty Boy Cat (221) | Jack and Susan Waggoner | Faron Hightower |
| 2000 | Sunolena Barrachone (221.5) | John and Doris Crump | Lloyd Cox |
| 1999 | Playin Stylish (222) | R.E. Merritt | Kathy Daughn |
| 1998 | Autumn Boon DNA (223) | Bill and Karen Freeman | Bill Freeman |
| 1997 | Flips Lil Angel (220) | John Hicks | Leon Harrel |
| 1996 | Playgun (222) | Dick Pieper | Jody Galyean |
| 1995 | Smart Aristocrat (221) | Jack Waggoner | Bill Freeman |
| 1994 | Hicapoo (221) | Jim and Mary Jo Milner | Paul Hansma |
| 1993 | Haidas Dude Ranches (222) | Silverbrook Ranches | Rodney Schumann |
| 1992 | Playboy Dan (217.5) | Skip and Gai Hamilton | Barbra Schulte |
| 1991 | Peppy Docs Mimosa (218.5) | Mike Winke | Bill Riddle |
| 1990 | Pop A Top Pep (223) | Stephen and Andre Bergeron | Ronnie Rice |
| 1989 | Sunettea Playgirl (221.5) | Joe Ayres | Jody Galyean |
| 1988 | Imari Tari (225) | Silverbrook Ranches | Buster Welch |
| 1987 | Lil Peppys Lena (221) | Silverbrook Ranches | Buster Welch |
| 1986 | Playboys Madera (221.5) | Marion Flynt | Terry Riddle |
| 1985 | Lynx Star Lady (219.5) | Larry and Ellen Reeder | Larry Reeder |
| 1984 | Royal Blue Boon (220.5) | Hall and Hambrick | Larry Reeder |
| 1983 | Peppymint Twist (221) | Marion Flynt | Buster Welch |
| 1982 | Tari Lynnea (223.5) | Dick Gaines | Dick Gaines |
| 1981 | Freckles Hustler (222.5) | Marion Flynt | Terry Riddle |
| 1980 | Pure Tari (220) | Bob Close | Pat Earnheart |
