Are we our brother's keeper or not?

  • Follow Letters

I'd like to thank Johnny Edwards for writing such a compassionate article ("Concentration of working poor rising," Aug. 12). I applaud Devon Harris for his work with Full Circle Refuge Youth Ministry.

The article made me think of Gene-sis 4:9: "Am I my brother's keeper?"

My great-grandfather J.P. McMichael, a local butcher, would, every Friday during the Great Depression, load up his Model T Ford with meat, and distribute it to the poor of Augusta. I remember when the late Mayor William Jennings, M.D., would make free house calls to treat those who could not afford medical care. These were men of character and ethics -- something that is lacking in today's political and religious leaders.

I feel it is a shame that political leaders in Augusta are more concerned with the special-interest groups that line their pockets with money.

I also feel it's a disgrace that a church would create policies that keep the very people away they should be serving, such as denying an elderly woman the right to hold her family reunion in the church her ancestors helped to build only because she no longer attends regularly because of advanced age and compromised health issues.

Instead of helping the poor in their community, our political and religious leaders would rather take money that is paid in taxes or put in offering plates to support their larger agendas. Why can't that money be used to help rebuild Augusta's failing infrastructure, or bring companies back so our citizens can have jobs again?

I ask Augusta: What has happened to the humanity and compassion of our political and religious leaders? We need to hold them accountable for their actions. We are our brother's keeper.

W. Michael Strickland, Atlanta

Comments

patriciathomas

Mr Strickland, I think you write of apples and comment on oranges. Helping the down and out isn't the same as providing an alternative life style on the backs of the productive. Giving aid isn't rewarding the grasshopper and punishing the ant. Today's subsidized remind me of the question,"If you carry a man real fast for a long time, how long before he becomes a great runner?". There's a difference between giving aid and enabling, and if Augusta doesn't learn to recognize this difference, it'll continue to deteriorate until it has no choice. Eventually, on August's current path, there'll be no Peter to rob to pay Paul.

mgroothand

Patriciathomas: Excellent, well worded and thought out 5:00 AM post. Sadly your statement applies to many cities and towns throughout this country.

I4PUTT

Everyone has the ability to pay back. Even the handicapped are generally capable of some tasks. Even if it's nothing more than walking along the roadside picking up the litter of the losers who throw their trash every where. I think many folks would be more inclined to help others if they saw a true effort of those in need to repay this aid. Here are some suggestions that some may find offensive. If you are receiving aid don't get pregnant, don't break the law, don't spend your money on alcohol or drugs, find something to do even if it's McDonalds, keep yourself clean and neat and job ready, can the attitude, be grateful, avoid the same mistakes that got you here, get an education, get some skill set, respect yourself and others, use your benefits for what they are intended, don't feed your dog steak, as a matter of fact if you can't support yourself how can you support pets, strive to do better. This will make it easier for your brother to keep you.

Bizarro

"Am I my brother's keeper" is Cain's answer to God's questioning knowing Cain had killed his brother Abel. It is an expression indicative of his guilt and conscience concerning his jealousy and murder. The LTE needs to use another verse for his thoughts. Better verses in regard to taking care of widows and the poor, but the responsiblity was on person not govt. and only the church in the sense of believers-the body of Christ (people in the church). I've seen the real poor and their true needs and appreciation for help, but I haven't seen that in the U.S. since the depression. I am sure there are really true poor in America, but the vast majority of classified poor are not wanting such as the poor elsewhere in the world.

accuracyplease

I am reminded of some of the teachings of Gandhi, which included his observation of the Sermon on the Mount, "If Christians really lived like that, Christianity would be unstoppable." He also said "A society is judged by how it treats the most vulnerable among its citizens." Look in the mirror. What have you done, besides spout scripture, to help others climb out of poverty and achieve a better life?

jack234

I agree with PT - the government should stop subsidizing the big oil companies and the farmers who are able to take advantage of our capitalistic system without government handouts. Obama-Nunn 08

Rozzie2003

Praise God for accuracyplease. He or she got it right.If so called Christains would live by the Good Book(Bible), this woulld be a better world. I am afraid of the so called Christains, who wear their religion on their sleeve only and hate thy neighbor or someone who is different. There are a lot of working poor in Augusta.Consider the hotel maids, retail clerks--especially Walmart, the janitors, the nursing home and day care workers,waiters and waitesses, lawn care people, etc. These people need much help. They are at the bottom of the economic ladder. I am in touch with a lot of the working poor daily and many of them have pride. Yet, they need food and a few dollars to tide them over during the month.The article Monday in the Chronicle regarding the working poor is correct. The working poor is among us and we act as if they weren't here.Visit the Board of Health, Salvation Army, Catholic Services, DFAC,Food Bank and other agencies that are doing God's Work.

jack

Rozzi- I always have to ask WHY these people are the "working poor". I am sure it was nothing I did. What was it they DIDN't do? Christians are the most giving people on earth to those who need it. We Christians do NOT believe in giving to those who are able to do for themselves but will help them to become self sufficient. The "working poor" in this country don't know what poor and doing without is unless they have been to such exotic places as the Philippines, Thailand, Mexico, Africa and other third world countries to which the US gives $billions each year. BTW, Christ also said that the poor would always be with us.

wm.strickland

Rozzie2003. God bless you. I am the writer of this letter. You spoke from your heart. I thank our Creator daily that there are people like you.

accuracyplease

For those who so glibly want to know why people are among the working poor, they might want to ask their church to participate in the poverty simulation "Welcome to the State of Poverty." It is offered often at colleges and through community programs and provides understanding to you who believe that the working poor are undeserving of Christian relief. http://www.ycp-povsim.org/How%20It%20Works.htm

Bizarro

I know a pediatrician friend who laments how working poor mothers children won't qualify for special medical treatments because the mother is working and not totally a dependent of the state. You are punished for success and working hard in this country anymore. Sad statement. I agree the working poor need help but I disagree they are truly poor in the sense of poverty as presented in other countries.

wm.strickland

Bizarro. I agree.

ForHim

I am not a so-called Christian. I am a Christian. Period. A good portion of the agencies that help the poor are aided in their efforts by churches thru food drives, drives to help the needs of the elderly, drives to donate toys at Christmas, drives to help those who need school supplies, to purchase fans in the heat of the summer, people who have been in an accident who were the sole provider for their family and can't work for a long period of time. In addition to providing we also teach our children to be compassionate and giving. It makes me sad when I hear people put down Christians for doing what they are supposed to do.

TakeAstand

Amen PT & I4PUTT, the working poor could receive the help they needed if the leeches that received all the subsidized stuff would be weeded out!! You do not deserve help if you do not take any initiative to better your life other than working hard at trying to find ways not to work and live off others!! No sympathy for these people at all, only for the children they breed into more leeches.

jack234

I agree with PT AND Takeastand, the government should stop subsidizing the big oil companies and the farmers who are able to take advantage of our capitalistic system without government handouts. Obama-Nunn 08

patriciathomas

I agree with jack234, Cuba gave us the example to follow for the past 50 years. Why weren't we smart enough to follow it. Obama '08

TakeAstand

At least they have jobs unlike the leeches!!!! A Hand out is to help those who beg for help, and the leeches do not beg for help they demand total support because they mistakingly think they are owed everything. Why are those you support not doing anything about he oil and stuff?? Because they are to busy giving things for free to the leeches rather than fighting the bigger problems that hurt the regular working family!!!

Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.
Loading...