Anglicans debate church's direction

  • Follow Your Faith

Any number of metaphors are used to describe the state of the Anglican Communion.

To some, it's a Titanic that's already struck its iceberg.

They believe, as Paul did, in the dangers of unequally "yoked" believers.

They say that the issue of homosexuals in church leadership, among others, too deeply divides the church and that schism is inevitable if, in fact, it hasn't already occurred.

Others counter with the metaphor of a crossroads. Though paths separate, the church can navigate its way to common ground. Schism is avoidable, they say.

The world's Anglican bishops are meeting for the first time since the U.S. Episcopal Church consecrated the first openly gay bishop, Gene Robinson, in 2003.

Every 10 years, bishops are invited to the two-week Lambeth Conference, which ends Sunday in Canterbury, England.

About 200 conservative bishops boycotted Lambeth this year and created the Global Anglican Future Conference with its own conference in Jerusalem.

The 650 bishops who attended Lambeth have debated a moratorium on the ordination of gay bishops and the blessing of homosexual ceremonies.

The plan was presented by a group of bishops tasked with finding solutions to the Communion's rift -- a division caused by several issues, not just the role of homosexuals in church leadership, said the Rev. Robert Fain, the rector of Church of the Good Shepherd on Walton Way.

"It's issues like how the Anglican Communion is organized, how it understands itself," he said. "It's about the church's understanding of marriage, of male and female, of sexuality in God's plan."

The Communion is a worldwide body with more than 70 million members -- the third-largest Christian denomination, behind the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches.

The Anglican Communion includes a range of worship styles and theological perspectives, including both conservative churches calling for an agreement that affirms a strict biblical interpretation prohibiting homosexuals in church leadership, and liberal churches that stress inclusiveness and congregational independence.

"It's the benefit of Anglicanism to me. We've got everything from the arch-conservative to the arch-liberal," said the Rev. Lou Scales, of The Church of Our Savior, on Columbia Road in Martinez.

A few years ago, The Church of Our Savior held an event titled "A Discussion With Gay and Lesbian Episcopalians," and has hired a senior warden who is gay.

"That kind of preference is incidental to us," the Rev. Scales said.

It isn't as incidental for others, said the Rev. Richard Sanders, the rector of St. Paul's Episcopal Church, on Reynolds Street. "There are people who have left St. Paul's on this issue -- both because we're not liberal enough and not conservative enough."

The issue, he said, is clearly divisive.

"It has affected us here at St. Paul's, locally, regionally, nationally and internationally," the Rev. Sanders said. "It's a terribly devastating thing for me. I grew up in this church. This crisis, and this issue, has been very hurtful."

The Rev. Fain agreed.

"Living with the ambiguity and the tensions has been very challenging," he said. "Some of us have the concern that this is drawing us away from our main mission."

The Rev. Sanders said that although the issue is important to him and to the people of St. Paul's, "it's not our priority here."

"We're focused on showing the love of Christ to the world," he said.

Perhaps, the Rev. Scales said, that's best done "by still gathering at the table, both in spite of and because of our differences."

Reach Kelly Jasper at (706) 823-3552 or


The Lambeth Conference is the meeting of the archbishops and bishops of the Anglican Communion every 10 years.

The first conference was held in 1867 at Lambeth Palace, the Archbishop of Canterbury's London home.

As the conference grew, the conference was relocated to the University of Kent at Canterbury.


Two Georgia churches have rejected the diocese, citing the ordination of homosexuals as an indication of deeper theological rifts in the church.

Last year, Christ Church in Savannah decided to leave the Diocese of Georgia because of the U.S. Episcopal Church's liberal leanings.

When Trinity Anglican Church was formed in Thomasville in 2006, it chose the leadership of a conservative Ugandan diocese instead of the Georgian diocese of the U.S. Episcopal Church.

"It's happening in various places around the country," said the Rev. James Parker, the rector of St. George's Church in Savannah. He spoke on behalf of the Georgia Diocese while its bishop, Henry L. Louttit, was at Lambeth.

The Rev. Sanders said that although St. Paul's Church is perhaps more conservative than others in the Episcopal Church, he doesn't think the issue will become a local problem soon.

"If the national Episcopal Church denied the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, we'd have a problem with that. Beneath that, it's tough to answer," he said.

The Rev. Fain says his church hasn't yet felt called to take a stance on the issue: "It doesn't help us proclaim Christ to pick a side."

Comments (3) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
robroi 08/02/08 - 07:02 am
One of the problems that the

One of the problems that the African bishops decried is that the name Anglican is becoming synonymous with the "gay church." This is harming their call to evangelize. Of course, here in the states, that impression is much more ingrained still. We have Gene Robinson giving interviews to anyone with a mike and mugging for every camera. Mr Robinson is well aware that he can make the orthodox's position simply untenable by changing the public perception. And, of course, we will have California blessing same sex unions in earnest in the coming months.

Parishes and priests that try to affirm scripture and tradition are undermined by the antics of Mr Robinson and the leftists in California.

If one looks at average Sunday attendance (a good measure of active members) of both parishes listed, one sees fairly substantial declines after 2003. St Pauls dropped from ~330 to ~250, a 24% drop and Our Savior dropped from ~180 to 160, an 11% drop.

The national church had actually grew in the late 1990's and early 2000's. Gene Robinson turned that around and last year the TEC was the FASTEST declining last year. This year will be much worse.

So the rectors should care.

Dixieman 08/02/08 - 07:07 pm
The Episcopal church left me

The Episcopal church left me a long time ago.

labdog98 08/03/08 - 02:07 pm
Dixieman, the Episcopal

Dixieman, the Episcopal church has never left. You walked out on her when she needed you the most.
Robroi, average attendance at Our Savior may have dropped but membership is up as well as meeting the budget. The Schaeffer Institute noticed a 2 % decline in all denominations in America from 1995 to 2002. Most churches today have a 2% gay population within them but it doesn't make them a "gay" church. Just as standing in a hen house doesn't make you a chicken. We at Our Savior are an all inclusive church. We invite all people to come sit at our table with Jesus Christ as your host. Come feel the Holy Spirit in our presence. We don't look for what's wrong in the Episcopal Church, we look for what's right. Come join us!

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs