In praise of snitching

  • Follow Editorials

Did you know that we're finally negotiating the withdrawal of our troops -- from New Orleans?

That's right. There are still 360 National Guardsmen in the city. They're supposed to leave beginning July 1, but Mayor Ray Nagin is hoping they won't.

Indeed, residents of New Orleans are tired of the crime. And a CNN report this week insinuates there are two New Orleans: a safe one for tourists, another, more dangerous one, for many residents.

Most types of violent crime are up in post-Katrina New Orleans, as similar crimes around the country are largely decreasing.

"Blood's not spilling in the French Quarter. But it is in many neighborhoods. And it's just not fair, natives say," CNN said. "Until somebody, somehow stops the rapes and shootings, some Katrina exiles refuse to come home."

Somebody? Somehow?

Mayor Nagin seems to suggest the power is in the people's hands.

"The citizens are stepping forward and saying, 'This is our city and we're going to fight for it and bring it back," he says.

We hope he's right. But the tenor of the CNN report seems to be that this problem is being "imposed" on New Orleans residents, and that somebody else ought to do something.

Not even an aggressive police force -- and New Orleans officers are working 12-hour shifts this summer -- can make neighborhoods safe.

That's up to the neighbors themselves.

And too often, they don't get involved and help police.

In fact, there's a sinister "Stop Snitching" campaign under way in various places across the country that actually and actively discourages people from cooperating with police in solving crimes.

Some authorities have said the stop-snitching campaign hasn't gotten much traction, and perhaps understandably: The ones who don't want you to snitch are normally the ones you'd be snitching on.

Still, the campaign is a virus spreading unhealthy attitudes toward police and law and order. And some officials say it's hurting law enforcement. A prosecutor in Pittsburgh once had to stop a victim of a crime -- a victim! -- from wearing a big, bold "Stop Snitching" T-shirt into court. The guy walked out, and let the case be dismissed, rather than turn his shirt inside-out.

That's just sick. And that kind of attitude helps make inner cities sick.

"In almost every one of my homicides, this happens: 'I don't know nothin' about nothin'," the Pittsburgh prosecutor told USA Today . "There is that attitude, 'Don't be a snitch.' And it's condoned by the community."

We don't know if the campaign has taken root in New Orleans, but it's the exact opposite of what's needed in all of our cities. People need to stop using their silence and complicity to enable criminals who are degrading the quality of life in urban America.

Fighting crime is as much about attitude as anything. You can't have the attitude that someone else is going to create the kind of community that you want.

And you can't treat the police like they're the enemy.

Comments

christian134

Really Chronicle what is the point of the story...We know that crime is a problem as to the why's it is glaringly simple...Where there is a total almost absolute absence of moral guidelines there will always be an increase of criminal behavior as well as a terrified silence coming from the victimized....I know of a young family in a nice residential neighborhood who are mortally afraid of their neighbors, drug dealers, instead of fighting to get them arrested they have put their house on the market...This is just one example, a rather insignificant instance, but it is all too familiar a happening in today's society...Until we bring back God, the family units and a definite right and wrong code to follow this criminal and terrified silence will only strengthen and spread..

shivas

Yet, we expect the US Army to do that for Iraq. Iraq is a quagmire and th everlasting drain upon any resources to help Americans.

dani

shivas, Thank goodness the "quagmire" is no longer that. The U.S. and Iraq are winning in this battle, finally, and getting better daily. Great achievements are being made by the Iraqi military such as taking back entire areas that were being held by the terrorist element.

deekster

Huuuummm. There was no terrorist element in Iraq until we put Hussein to death. I'm for protecting America First, but this "colonial island in the Mideast" is being established for other purposes. The news media is lying to the American people. We have not won a was since our policy became "regime change and occupation". World War II was a "total and utter defeat, surrender and rebuild" strategy. No more. We have the military power, right now, to strike with "sudden and total destruction" to any place on the globe. Why are we playing with "want a be Hitlers". Political power and greed. The government continues to recruit civilians to work in Iraq. One and two year contracts, income tax free.
Want to make $100k a year?

deekster

Our military men and women can win any conflict if left to military means. They can complete any mission if the politicians would remove themselves from the field of battle. Policing a "civil war" is a no win situation. Muslims do not want a "democracy". They want a "theocrary", but can't agree on the "doctrine".

battlecataclysmic

The No Snitching campaign truly is a plague. But, once again, this is what happens when you live in a society of social division along racial and economic lines. "Stop Snitching" only came about because of an inner city population that has been largely neglected by the middle and upper classes for decades and, as a result, left to their own methods for survival. Unfortunately, those methods weren't always legal--- by choice or by felt necessity--- and so bad blood arose between communities and the police. Not to mention, every police officer in these areas hasn't always been an upstanding example, adding more fuel to the fire. Result: total distrust of law enforcement. However, people in the inner cities fail to realize that protecting regular criminals does nothing but create an even MORE dangerous environment for everyone. The hood used to be a place of togetherness even in poverty, but the breakdown of the family has resulted in a much more "every-man-for-himself" attitude. Therefore, not snitching is not protecting a proverbial "Robin Hood" as they're led to believe, but alotting yet another place for self-destruction. Criminals get away only to become new oppressors.

mgroothand

New Orleans/Katrina is a good example of what happens when you have a community leader that commandeers National Guard helicopters for personal gain in a time of crisis, hide $90K in a freezer and don't bother going to trial while getting reelected.

jack

More drooling on yourself Shivas? Ths country (at least most parts of it minus DC, NOLA, Detroit, Atlanta, LA , Baltimore) live under the rule of law. This is something the Iraqis have to learn. The use of troops in this country to do the work of the pocie is against the law (you probably too ignorant to know this). Obviously, you are also too ignorant to tell the difference. Shivas, you are just ignorant-you show it on here every day.

jack

(typo correction)More drooling on yourself Shivas? This country (at least most parts of it minus DC, NOLA, Detroit, Atlanta, LA , Baltimore) live under the rule of law. This is something the Iraqis have to learn. The use of troops in this country to do the work of the police is against the law (you probably too ignorant to know this). Obviously, you are also too ignorant to tell the difference. Shivas, you are just ignorant-you show it on here every day.

shivas

Jack, I think you want to support the Iraqi people more than Americans. The right-wing has strange priorities.

motivatedinhepzibah

If these people do tell on others. Will the police really help them when the others find out that they told on them. Its not about stop snitching really. Its about what happens to people who do snitch. Nobody wants to be in witness protection their whole life. Or end up dead for something they have nothing to do with.

nightraiders1

NO was a piece of crap city before Katrina and is still one after. Nothing has changed. The epitome of the gimme, gimme, society that is backing b-barack!

mgroothand

Nightraiders: I agree about NO, try taking your family on a leisurely stroll down Bourbon St. There are no signs saying "R" or "you must be 18+ to enter".

FallingLeaves

But if you don't snitch, or report, or witness, or whatever you want to call your CIVIC DUTY, you're going to wind up a victim anyway, because things will keep getting worse. This is a dangerous plague. Don't come crying to me when you wouldn't do the right thing and then wind up a victim.

Bizarro

Well the state of Florida is sinking faster than originally predicted. Is the govt going to save south florida like it has tried to save NO??? I vote save Florida and let NO sink, but I own property there so I am biased.

Bizarro

Back in the 70's I had some experiences with the criminal element. My dearly departed friend, Pablo Escobar, had some great pointers on how to deal with situations like this. Hee,hee,hee. I think Nagin knew him too so I am surprised at his failure. You have to be more scary than your opposition, and get them on the run.

FallingLeaves

Bizarro, that reminds me: The only thing that ever scared one of my neighbors that I did, (because I never had the inclination, time or energy to TRY to scare them) was one lovely evening I decided to practice my Tai Chi on the front deck in the shade. I do have some privacy there, but just not from across the street. I never knew when they were home or not because they didn't have a car, so I just did my Tai Chi very slowly as a warm up, then started doing the form a little faster each time, several times in a row, until it looked more like the later martial arts forms instead of the defensive moves it was designed to be. I glanced up near the end of the last moves and my neighbor was standing there wide eyed and slack-jawed. It was the first time I ever saw her look scared and I hadn't even meant to scare her. I guess her guilt kind of contributed to that. She didn't harass me anymore for awhile. I wish I'd practiced on the porch years ago, would have save me a lot of stress.

KSL

As to what is going on in NO, what we have here is a prime example of the Peter Principle. Ray Nagin has demonstrated that he is a fine example of that theory (though he is elected) since he came into the national limelight.

Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.
Loading...