Sometimes silence not golden

  • Follow Editorials

Ben Harbin says his silence has been a mistake.

But has he broken it?

The Evans Republican and state House Appropriations Committee chairman sent a letter to constituents last week apologizing for what amounts to a media blackout since his May 2007 arrest for DUI in Atlanta.

But just over a month before the July 15 primary, Harbin's letter sheds no light on the matter -- while saying "I felt you were entitled to hear about this directly from me."

Hear what, though? He says in the letter that "you are entitled to straight answers from those who represent you" -- but, again, he offers no answers, straight or otherwise.

"I apologize if the legal process in this case has created the appearance that I have not been completely forthcoming," he writes.

It's more than an appearance. He hasn't been forthcoming for a year. And he still isn't.

"I wish that I had chosen differently from the beginning," he adds.

So do we. But even at this late date, it's not too late. He still has a chance to be forthcoming before the July 15 primary.

The question is, will he?

Harbin says in the letter that "I have always accepted responsibility for my actions, and this issue is no different."

Really? So he always puts off accepting responsibility for over a year?

Ben Harbin is a good guy and a good legislator, and there have been some delays in the case that haven't been his fault. But as the person charged, he has always had the power to accept responsibility -- whatever that's supposed to mean, since he won't say whether he did it or not.

The delay in his taking responsibility has only made the case worse for his reputation. A quick plea last year, and this would be mostly a memory. Now it's central to his re-election campaign, as evidenced by his letter.

He's still got the chance to accept responsibility, get the case cleared up and stand for questions before the July 15 primary. In fact, he owes that to his constituents -- not just a vague mass-mailed apology that doesn't really say anything but tries to leave the impression of a stand-up guy.

His next hearing, last we heard, was scheduled for June 24. If it gets put off until after the July 15 election, his "accepting responsibility" will ring hollow.

Comments

christian134

This man is no different that anyone who happens to be arrested for a DUI except for the fact he is a public official...As such his behavior is to be above board. DUI's are reprehensible for anyone as they are potential weapons of death and destruction but for a Representative he is to be held to a higher standard...For him to remain quite is like a child hiding his eyes so he can become invisible but you and I know that it is not the correct behavior that is displayed in a reasonably mature and somewhat responsible adult ...He needed to speak out as soon as the was charged. If guilty be upright and take his punishment like a "man" so to speak if not then inform the public just don't stay silent....Ben Harbin your constituents have a right to know..

shivas

His behavior is much different. He has been accused of manipulating the system, lying to law enforcement, in order to keep his license. This is unacceptable for anyone. If anything, he is being treated much easier than the average person who gets a DUI. The cover-up of his behavior will be his undoing.

I4PUTT

shivas I agree in part with what you say. The only thing I would change is that it should be his undoing. Dishonesty, irresponsibility, lawlessness and elitism are not attractive traits for an elected servant of the people. He has had enough chances to do what is right. Vote accordingly!

WHATDIDIDO

His supporters do not care about honor. They only care about what he can do for them. Only when it's someone else represenative, do they believe in taking responsibility.

Bizarro

I wonder if he were a Dem would he receive the same chastisement? The law has never been blind. The rich and powerful always get a better share of justice than the poor and weak (look at our prisons). I can't tell you how many times I recall a poor fool going to jail and a rich man walking. I can imagine if I were in his position and a similar accident befell me I would be embarrassed and wish the whole thing would just go away. He screwed up-give him a break. We have a person who admit to a felony-Barak Obama-running for president (he admits to cocaine and drug usage). I don't have a problem with that. Look at Ted Kennedy who has served a lifetime after his drunk accident with a death envolved (he also left the scene of the crime, so he would have served some time nowadays). I smell hypocrisy.

ThurstonHowell

Yeah, it's not like he got drunk and drowned someone.

junebug

He almost hit a phantom pedestrian. Good thing a light pole is all he rammed.

jack

HYPO says "His supporters do not care about honor. They only care about what he can do for them. Only when it's someone else represenative, do they believe in taking responsibility." Sounds like he is talking about Charles Walker.

Bizarro

Jack you seem to imply Hypo's moniker reflects well on his character? There is an excellent article on this phenomenon in a recent Science article: How We See Ourselves and How We See Others. Emily Pronin. Science 30 May 2008: 1177-1180. People see themselves differently from how they see others. They are immersed in their own sensations, emotions, and cognitions at the same time that their experience of others is dominated by what can be observed externally. This basic asymmetry has broad consequences. It leads people to judge themselves and their own behavior differently from how they judge others and those others' behavior. Often, those differences produce disagreement and conflict. Understanding the psychological basis of those differences may help mitigate some of their negative effects. I would encourage everyone to read Science or Scientific American to keep abreast of news in science. I started with S.A. and as my knowledge grew I moved up to Science-which is pretty technical. That and a good Bible. Hee,hee. My wife says I should have been a scientist-that or a theologian. Life is full of paradox.

robbie1

This man has every right to use every tool available to him in his defense. He also has the right to remain silent so as not to offer evidence against himself. He apparantly has chosen to remain silent while telling his constituants that he is coming clean... Can't have it both ways. I am sure the facts will come out once the trial is over. Then you will see if he has had a momentary lapse of judgement, or has tried to use his position to get out of trouble. With the implied poor judgement, and the accusations of misuse of power, I would find it difficult to cast a vote for this man to represent me.

christian134

Jack that is so true...My word people came out in droves to stand up for Charles Walker..He was found guilty but it was all someone else's fault ...He was even reelected to another term in office..."His supporters must not care about honor..They only care about what he can do for them"....This is a double standard that has been all to normal these past years...Wrong is wrong and should be handled as such no matter the color or the political affiliation that person is involved...

DAMY46

Is Harbin still married?

Donald

2centsworth

We don't know what demons plague poor Ben. Drink might be one...some say there may be others. Maybe its best to let him stay home and focus on his family. I know only a little about his opponent but maybe its time to let someone else represent our values...I'm not sure Ben still does.

shivas

Defending someone's unacceptable behavior on the basis that others do it proves patriciathomas' point that this is a decline in society. Even she sees the rub in this Harbin affair.

Bizarro

I don't think anyone is defending Harbin, rather saying this has become the norm. I have already stated he should be out but if we were to hold all politicians to a higher standard of behavior we would be out of politicians. I wonder how many of us posters would hold up to scrutiny. If I were treated as I deserve I should either be just getting out of prison or burning in the Lake of Fire. hee,hee. Bizarro was bad, bad, bad, bad, bad, bad to de bone. Bizarro clever enough not to get caught for any major offenses. Maybe I should run for office. I have offered sound political decisions like my:Beat Your Child's Behind Act for education, GOYAW Act for energy-get off your [filtered word] and walk act, No Tax Act with the public only paying for govt services that work competitively in a free market (no more $100 dollar hammers), Big Stick Act where diplomacy works because we threaten with nuclear annihilation anyone who doesn't do our biding. Vote Bizarro 08!!!!!

shivas

I think it's different when conservatives get busted because they are the one who preach morals and religion so much. If your doing the bad stuff, don't be the loudest one persecuting others for doing it. People who go out of their way to present themselves as holy, while painting the liberals as lacking family values, are just setting themselves up for the proverbial fall that is inevitable to come. We all knew Bill Clinton's history before becoming Pres. However, Clinton never went around moralizing about others.

abrooke20

I'm honestly tired of hearing bad things about Representative Harbin! Has everyone forgotten innocent until proven guilty? This man has every right, representative or civilian, to fight this case and stay quiet. If anybody saw the debate on Comcast Monday night I hope everyone would recognize that the downfall of district 118 would be if Lee Benedict was elected not a DUI case that has not been settled. Wake up Columbia County!! We need Ben Harbin to to keep making the necessary advances we have in this community like he has been making for the past decade and a half.

WHATDIDIDO

If any of you have been reading my posts for any period of time, you would know that I am no Walker supporter. I know that throws a wrench, in your all Black support each other, but when you assumes, it makes an ....well you know the rest. In this election I have supported Hillary from start to finish. Hum... another hole in your Blacks will always vote for the Black candidate. Christian, the word honor should not come out of your nor Jack's mouth.

christian134

Oh come off it hypo the black bit....Actually whites are notorious for not holding up for each other particularly if they are wrong..When a person is overwhelming supported then chances are he will be of the black persuasion...Just as I have always supported Bush right now I have run just about as far away as I can possibly get...It is not something to get all heated up about...:-)

WHATDIDIDO

Oh yeah Christian, Blacks are always supporting the criminal type. You know what, I will stop here. I already know your mindset, it would be a waste of time, trying to prove what race will or will not support this or that person. You have your opinion, I have mine.

Bizarro

Well shivas you know that preaching about morals and religion is different from actually following them. It gets pretty old for me to ask God to forgive me for the same sin I've committed over and over again. I can only imagine what God thinks. You know about the elect and how God chooses us and how we should hear his voice. Well I think I got disconnected, or he has unelected me.

shivas

I only preach to my kids to make good decisions. Success in life is about decisions you make. Although I see myself as successful, I have made many poor decisions in my teens and early adulthood that I wish I could take back. Harrisburg upbringing in the 70's. However, that is part of growth and who I am, and regrets can only be a negative influence. Also, I am sure strength was gained from overcoming some bad influences. Unfortunately, the rich and powerful rarely suffer the consequences that cause them to change their behavior. Ben Harbin is who he is, and will continue to make risky decisions because he will avoid consequences.

nightraider

You said it hippyhiho in your 5:08 post. True thoughts usually come out in idiots, you win again hip!

Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.
Loading...