Who will stand up to bullies in BCS?

  • Follow Scott Michaux

They sat, talked and did nothing.

The commissioners of the much-maligned Bowl Championship Series met this week in sunny South Florida and collectively stuck their heads in the sand. The commissioners from all 11 Division I-A conferences, plus Notre Dame's athletic director, showed the same kind of commitment Congress does in dealing with the overwhelming sentiments of the public.

Jim Delany, the haughty commish of the Big Ten, says it's not his conference's fault or the Pac-10's or the Rose Bowl's for building the roadblock to a meaningful playoff system that the vast majority of fans are crying for after the repeated fiascoes of an ill-designed system. He banks on the idea that the rest of the conferences don't have the guts to override the standing veto the Rose Bowl and its exclusive TV deal and conference tie-ins represent.

And he's right. The Big East's Mike Tranghese spoke like just another lemming steering the best interests of college football off the cliff.

"We don't think a playoff is in the best interest of college football," Tranghese was quoted as saying.

"If it ain't broke, don't fix it," said Notre Dame's Kevin White, who can't even stop the tarnish build-up on his Golden Dome.

It is broken, you idiots. It was built broken.

The only commissioners to exhibit even the slightest backbone and voice reservations about a revolting system that turns off the public were the Southeastern's Mike Slive and the Atlantic Coast's John Swofford. But it fell on Swofford, the current caretaker of the whole mess, to put a brave face on it at the end.

"The BCS is in an unprecedented state of health," he said at the meeting's end, towing a party line even he can't believe after witnessing repeated unfilled stadiums for his beloved ACC championship game and inconsequential bowls.

Slive -- whose conference is the healthiest of all -- in particular seemed disheartened that his "plus-one" proposal was so easily dismissed Wednesday.

"It's a marathon, not a sprint," Slive told reporters. "It is on the table, and it's there now. Everyone knows it's there."

What's there is the reality that nobody is willing to give up their guaranteed postseason checks for a system that would be truly open and appealing. We're stuck with the same ol' garbage for at least six more years -- and I'm sure the Rose Bowl axis will renegotiate its own selfish extension to the national misery before then.

What's needed is a full-scale mutiny. It's time to blow the smug right off Delany's face with a real playoff proposal that dares everyone to either get on board or wave from the sidelines. It's time to detonate the nuclear option that will eviscerate the stupid BCS system and establish a real postseason that everyone craves.

It's time to let the Rose Bowl crowd play with their own ball while the rest of the game advances into the modern era. They've been calling the shots and making their own contracts for too long. They aren't real partners in all this. They don't care what's best for anybody but themselves.

Slive's four-team seeded version of the "plus-one" band-aid the BCS has been bandying about for years was not the answer, and he knows it. Only a truly inclusive system of at least eight teams will stave off more controversies than it creates.

The stop-gap plan was too weak to begin with. It didn't address any of the concerns that qualified teams would still get excluded from the mix. If the scenario existed last year, both Georgia and Southern Cal would have been excluded, and many thought they were the two best teams in the BCS postseason landscape.

So next time these blowhards get together in a luxury conference room to feign discussion on behalf of their constituents, drop the bomb on them. Propose a real playoff, line up a TV partner who will pay gobs more than the current series gets and invite anyone willing to participate to join in the fun. No conference unwilling to send its champion gets to reap any of the shared rewards or take any of the at-large spots.

The teams would love it. The players would love it. The fans would love it.

The only people who wouldn't love it would be Delany and his crowd of obstructionists, who would stare at it through their Rose-colored glasses with great envy while claiming that Pasadena is all they'll ever need.

Then one of his member schools will win the conference and jump the Rose Bowl ship and this whole stupid era of illegitimate postseasons will sink into oblivion.

It will take brave leaders such as the kind who declared independence from tyranny more 230 years ago to do what's right. Men with more vision than the ones who let us all down this week.

Where is Commissioner John Adams when you need him?

Reach Scott Michaux at (706) 823-3219 or scott.michaux@augustachronicle.com.

Comments (5) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
radioactive 05/02/08 - 08:04 am
The only way to implement a

The only way to implement a playoff system is with our pocketbooks. Football fans are going to watch the games no matter who plays, but what if we band together and make our voice heard that we will not buy any product or use any service of a TV sponsor of the BCS. We, the all powerful customer, can make this happen. Its all about the money.

lrgk9 05/03/08 - 10:03 am
Go on Scott, why stop there?

Go on Scott, why stop there? Delve into the character defects of the little gray suited men throughout history. No vision and leadership in this bunch. ......................................................................................................................................................... Heck - let's toss caution to the wind - like Hitler's Generals - they confer and meet and talk about what's right - but they are at bottom self centered smug politicals who are enamored of their stipend positions. Unwilling to look at themselves for the chaff amongst the wheat they are becoming - the whole bunch accedes to the Machavellian tactics of the Pac 10, Jimmy Delany, and the Rose bowl. ........................................................................................................................................................... Bottom line - a whole set of pompous doublespeaking backboneless sidewinders who amount to no more than bugs on the windshield of college football needing to be wiped off and sent to find real jobs...

thetroll 05/04/08 - 01:24 pm
to lrgk9 do you actually have

to lrgk9 do you actually have an opinion or did you just want to impress all of us with your command of the english language

GameCock BoB
GameCock BoB 05/04/08 - 05:53 pm
The writer of this article

The writer of this article doesnt get it. The college bowl games and their revenue are the only thing the NCAA does not control.

Scott Michaux
Scott Michaux 05/07/08 - 07:42 am
Actually, GameCock BoB, I do

Actually, GameCock BoB, I do get it. And I don't care if the NCAA controls the strings of a legitimate college football postseason or the same BCS commanders. Just create a postseason playoff and count your money. There is no reason the rest of the bowl structure needs to be dismantled. It can't get any more meaningless than it already is. But if it makes 7-5 teams feel good about themselves and gives them some kind of incentive, so be it. Just do something to create a real national champion. That's all I ask.

Back to Top
Top headlines
Former VA supervisor convicted of false statements in veterans' medical records
Cathedral Henderson, 51, of Martinez was found guilty of 50 counts of making false statements in relation to health care and one count of making false statement to a federal agent.
Search Augusta jobs