Richmond County schools should emphasize academics, not athletics

  • Follow Letters

After reading the Nov. 20 Augusta Chronicle article "Middle school athletics failing," I feel that, as a former educator for the Richmond County Board of Education, I should respond.

It's my belief that the Richmond County school system is divided into two distinct categories. There are the true scholastic and academically oriented schools, and there are the athletic schools. Of course, it's no secret that this school system seems to place great emphasis on school athletic success in comparison to academic success.

THIS SCHOOL system's athletic programs appears to overshadow academic school programs at the majority of middle and high schools in the county. And it's a fact that the athletic schools are the schools that have the majority of students of color. What is wrong with this picture? It's easy to identify the athletic schools because these schools are only spotlighted for athletic success, and never for positive academic accomplishments.

Of course, this scenario reminds me of what occurred on slave plantations in the antebellum South. People of color were considered by their slave masters to be only physically strong and athletic to perform hard labor on the plantation. But they were considered to be incapable of performing chores that required them to use their intelligence and think logically. Am I to assume that our urban public schools have become modern-day plantations to exploit athletes of color for their physical attributes?

I once attended an education forum with peer educators, level-one school administrators, school principals and board members. A discussion about school athletics vs. school academics arose. There was a general sentiment among the majority of people present that there should always be a balance between athletics and academics within the system. I told them they were deluding themselves. Anyone with an ounce of intelligence knows that academics must always be the No. 1 priority and mission for any public or private educational institution in America. Isn't this the reason why schools were created?

IF SCHOOLS aren't competently educating students, then these educational institutions are failing the high educational expectations that are promoted by our American society.

It was proposed in the newspaper article that middle-school athletes should be evaluated twice a week to see how they are performing academically. This would be unfair to the nonathlete student body. Shouldn't all of the pupils be evaluated twice weekly to make sure that everyone is making solid academic progress, and not just athletes? Showing favoritism to athletes and ignoring other members of the school population is a twisted concept. I cannot accept this idea because it's absolutely wrong.

Since the Richmond County school system enrollment is composed of about 72 percent of pupils of color, I'm annoyed by the fact that academics must take a back seat to athletics for these children. Have our urban public schools become slave plantations to promote physical brawn over intelligence? Does this perpetuate the stereotype that pupils of color are natural-born athletes, but lack natural-born intelligence to excel academically?

I'M PROUD that I don't buy into such notions. And it's really sad for school board members, administrators and teachers of color to passively perpetuate these mythical notions by not challenging, and setting high expectations for, these pupils. It's time for everyone to embrace the fact that pupils of color not only are capable of being successful athletes, but capable of leading our nation to high levels of success because of their intelligence, talents and creativity.

(The writer is a former Richmond County public school teacher with 31 years of teaching service. He lives in Augusta.)

Comments (5) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
mgroothand 12/09/07 - 08:13 am
Mr. Maner does and should

Mr. Maner does and should know what he is talking about. Tell it like it is. Bravo!

karmakills123 12/09/07 - 09:14 am
Great LTE.......but are the

Great LTE.......but are the people of color going to listen??

wisdomofyears 12/09/07 - 11:06 am
Edward Maner thinks like I

Edward Maner thinks like I do. We have forced athletics so much in our schools that it matters not whether our students learn anything or not. No wonder Pres Bush said in a speech, soon after he became President, our students are not taking subjects to qualify them for the high paying jobs in America. We HAVE to import doctors, scientists, etc from other nations to fill our high paying jobs. Thank you, E Maner for saying what many of us already knew.

gcap 12/09/07 - 01:29 pm
Richmond County once had

Richmond County once had balance in the school system -- in all schools, in all communities. That was decades ago. Nowadays, especially during the Charles Larke era, education has taken a back seat to everything else. Finding that balance will be very much a challenge for the Richmond County BOE. Why? It's nearly impossible to re-educate students in the system. They'll just have to start over with the entering first graders. That won't work either, because the same teachers in the system won't know how to do it right.

keysplease 12/09/07 - 08:58 pm
I agree. I love sports and

I agree. I love sports and support those students who are gifted athletically. However, I am tired of hearing announcements at my school that praise the sports teams, yet ignore those students who are Governor's Honors semi-finalists, STAR students, honor roll students, winners of the Academic Bowls, etc. One thing that no one talks about is the issue of money. Football and basketball teams bring in money. I know most of the funds cover expenses that the school system doesn't cover, so they have to put people in the seats. Coaches receive supplements to their salaries for an entire year, even though their commitments to their particular sport may only be from August-December. Plus, don't forget the athletic boosters in each school that demand coaches to take their teams to the playoffs every year. We really do need to reflect upon what our priorities are in the school system.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs