Writer's assertions need clarifying

  • Follow Letters

In a March 21 letter ("Where's the real deception here?"), Mary Beth Pierucci, director of external affairs for Planned Parenthood of Augusta wrote a personal and misleading attack upon Vern Simon.

In a March 9 letter ("Students for Choice: a great deception"), Mr. Simon noted that a Medical College of Georgia group known as Medical Students for Choice had sponsored two forums on the abortion issue. These were open to the public as they should have been. Apparently, MSFC was displeased that several MCG staff, faculty and retired MCG faculty attended and asked some pointed questions. Subsequently, these forums were closed to the public, a point Mr. Simon said was contrary to academic freedom and informed choice.

Mr. Simon also said that tax money pays for some abortions.

For these statements, Ms. Pierucci termed Mr. Simon an "extremist who spins untruths." Further, Pierucci said "on two occasions I have personally witnessed Mr. Simon and his group attempt to control a Medical Students for Choice forum."

Well, maybe some of the "real deception" resides with Ms. Pierucci.

Regarding taxpayer support, interested readers should Google "federal support" and "Planned Parenthood." The result will illuminate astounding Planned Parenthood profit and large indirect federal support for abortion services. Not a pretty picture.

Regarding Mr. Simon and his "group" attempting to control a MSFC forum, there is no "group." One questioner was a former chairman of a major MCG clinical department; others were MCG staff, faculty and retired faculty. I asked a question (I'm retired MCG faculty). Difficult questions do not "control" a forum - even if the answer is contrary to Planned Parenthood goals.

Finally, Mr. Simon is correct about the responsibility of MCG to open such forums. Unless the Medical Students for Choice is a shill for Planned Parenthood, this only seems reasonable.

William J. Jackson, North Augusta, S.C.

Comments (1) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
MCG MedicalStudent
MCG MedicalStudent 03/29/07 - 02:23 pm
actually, every registered

actually, every registered student group on campus at MCG, whether it is Medical students for Choice, The Medical Repulicans, Medical Campus Outreach, AMWA, Student interest groups, etc..., has the right under MCG policy to limit attendance to their School's students, residents, CURRENT faculty and staff. Students PAY for these groups, and the public has no business interferring with meetings for only medical students or any other campus group. If you want to come, go back to school!

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
Augusta VA supervisor sentenced to prison
In what the judge called a "tragic case," a former Charlie Norwood VA Medical Center supervisor was sentenced Thursday to 27 months in federal prison for making false statements in medical files.