Jurors convict Couey of murder

  • Follow Metro

MIAMI - Convicted sex offender John Evander Couey was found guilty Wednesday of kidnapping, raping and murdering 9-year-old Jessica Lunsford by burying her alive inside trash bags, a case that drew national attention to the problem of tracking sexual criminals.

Back | Next
John Couey listens to the verdict rendered by a six-man, six-woman jury in Miami. The jury returns Tuesday to start on the penalty phase.  Associated Press
Associated Press
John Couey listens to the verdict rendered by a six-man, six-woman jury in Miami. The jury returns Tuesday to start on the penalty phase.

Jurors deliberated about four hours before returning guilty verdicts on all charges. When the jury returns Tuesday for the sentencing phase, it will decide whether to recommend Mr. Couey, 48, be sentenced to death.

As the verdicts were read, Mr. Couey stood staring straight ahead and swayed slightly. Jessica's father, Mark Lunsford, showed no emotion, nor did her grandparents, Ruth and Archie Lunsford.

Prosecutors cited overwhelming physical evidence and Mr. Couey's own admissions about committing the crime.

"She had a constitutional right to the pursuit of happiness," prosecutor Peter Magrino told jurors in a closing statement. "That defendant right there took away her constitutional rights when he murdered her."

Evidence presented at trial included DNA from Jessica's blood and Mr. Couey's semen on a mattress in his room, plus Jessica's fingerprints in a nearby closet where she was allegedly hidden. Jail guards and investigators testified that Mr. Couey repeatedly admitted details of the slaying after his arrest, insisting that he hadn't meant to kill the third-grader but panicked during a nationally publicized police search.

Couey attorney Daniel Lewan, in a brief 15-minute closing statement, tried to shift the focus to unanswered questions, such as how Jessica was taken silently from her home and why analysis was not done on other fingerprints in Mr. Couey's room. He suggested that the police focus on Mr. Couey was driven by media and community pressure to solve the case.

"Don't be afraid to disregard what you don't trust," he said. "Use your logic and common sense."

Jessica's body was unearthed from a shallow hole about three weeks after she disappeared, encased in two black plastic trash bags. She died of suffocation and was found clutching a purple stuffed dolphin. Two fingers on her right hand were poking through the plastic.

Mr. Couey confessed to investigators shortly after his arrest, but that confession was thrown out because he did not have a lawyer present as he had requested.

Citrus County Circuit Judge Richard Howard will decide whether Mr. Couey should be sentenced to death. He is not required to follow the jury's recommendation.

Couey defense lawyers have already laid the groundwork for mitigating circumstances such as mental illness and mental retardation in an effort to spare him the death penalty. Whether by design or not, Mr. Couey spent much of the trial drawing and coloring with colored pencils while seated at the defense table.

Mr. Couey has a prior record as a sex offender. He was arrested in March 2005 in Augusta during a massive search for Jessica, who disappeared from her bedroom the night of Feb. 23, 2005, about 150 yards from the central Florida trailer where Mr. Couey had been living.

Jessica's killing led Florida and other states to pass new laws to crack down on sex offenders and improve tracking of them, including creation of a new U.S. Justice Department database. Authorities did not know Mr. Couey was living near the Lunsford home even though he was required to tell them he had moved.

Comments (8) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Ole School
0
Points
Ole School 03/08/07 - 06:45 am
0
0
bury him too

bury him too

Jenn30907
0
Points
Jenn30907 03/08/07 - 07:30 am
0
0
Don't forget to make sure

Don't forget to make sure he's alive before he's buried and after he's castrated! An eye for an eye!

mgroothand
5
Points
mgroothand 03/08/07 - 08:18 am
0
0
If ever the death penalty is

If ever the death penalty is an appropriate sentence then certainly this is the case. I'm surprised it took the jurors all of four hours to find him guilty. The only good that has come out of this is Jessica's law.

WORRIEDPARENT
0
Points
WORRIEDPARENT 03/08/07 - 10:14 am
0
0
fry him or whatever florida

fry him or whatever florida does now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

adrian22
1
Points
adrian22 03/08/07 - 12:26 pm
0
0
Poor child. When are we going

Poor child. When are we going to stop letting these creeps get away with this. Everyone is on this plea of insanity. He is insane for the even thought of doing this to a person. However, he should pay for his crime. That little girl suffered much and he deserves the same.

Cody_Webster
0
Points
Cody_Webster 03/08/07 - 02:27 pm
0
0
Cut him loose, but make him

Cut him loose, but make him the designated baby sitter for any bleeding heart that's against putting his kind away forever (jail or dead).

Grandma
0
Points
Grandma 03/08/07 - 08:13 pm
0
0
I am haunted by the mental

I am haunted by the mental images of that baby suffocating inside those garbage bags. I have a grandaughter the same age and it terrifies me everytime I think about it. In this case, there is no punishment that fits the crime.

crymeariver
0
Points
crymeariver 03/08/07 - 11:38 pm
0
0
why is it that every time

why is it that every time someone commits a murder, they say they are mentally ill. if they are, how come they didnt get help before they killed someone. nowadays, you can kill 3 babies, a mom, 2 brothers and rape a grandmother all in the same day, and come out of court with 6 months probation. maybe if one of these sickos would do something horrible to some of these lawmakers families, the laws would change to protect innocent people like those little girls. hey lawmakers and judges, just remember that little girl under the ground wrapped up in trash bags squeezing her little stuffed animal fighting for her last breath. i hope you sleep good tonight with your children.

Back to Top

Search Augusta jobs