Originally created 11/29/06

It's time for Wie to change course



For someone who grew up in Hawaii, Michelle Wie picked the perfect metaphor to explain her recent struggles.

"Golf goes in waves," she said.

She was on the kind of wave found in winter at Waimea Bay earlier this year when she came within a whisker of becoming the youngest major champion in history, at the Kraft Nabisco Championship and the LPGA Championship. The biggest wave she caught might have been at Canoe Brook, when only a shaky putter kept Wie from becoming the first woman to qualify for the U.S. Open.

Now, nearly every ride ends with a spectacular wipeout.

The latest was last week in Japan, where the 17-year-old Wie failed to break 80 in either of the first two rounds of the men's Casio World Open and beat only one player.

The senior at Punahou School in Honolulu has gone back to the books for the final month of a tumultuous year, but Wie is eager to get back in the water. Asked if her latest crash would deter her from playing against the men, she replied, "Not at all."

Wie played seven times against the men this year, with an average score of 75.07 in 15 rounds. She broke par four times, twice at the SK Telecom Open when she became the first woman to make the cut on the Asian Tour.

The most recent time Wie experienced winning was in 2004 at the Curtis Cup, a victory she shared with seven other amateurs. The last trophy she hoisted on her own was the 2003 U.S. Women's Amateur Public Links at age 13.

She changed caddies in August. She changed agents in October.

The next thing she should consider changing is her course.

Wie is not about to give up her dream of competing against the men, whether that's a realistic goal of earning a paycheck on the PGA Tour or her fantasy of playing in the Masters.

But, for now, the next paper she writes should be a letter to LPGA commissioner Carolyn Bivens asking that the age requirement (18) be waived so Wie can join the tour.

The Wie camp seriously considered asking to join the LPGA Tour, but instead will stick to the plan of Wie playing part-time against the women and men, enjoying her senior year of high school and deciding where to go to college next year (her family has ties to Stanford and UCLA).

Joining the LPGA Tour, however, makes good sense.

The LPGA counts money from domestic tournaments with at least 75 players in the field, which limits Wie to the Fields Open, the Kraft Nabisco Championship and the LPGA Championship (the U.S. Women's Open doesn't count because its purse is so large). With only those three tournaments, she still earned $238,913, well inside the top 90 on the money list to apply for membership.

Joining the LPGA would be a detour, not an about-face.

More than anything, it would give Wie better options in building a schedule. Without an LPGA Tour card, she can play only eight times against the women - six sponsors' exemptions, the U.S. Women's Open and the Women's British Open. To fill in the holes, she wound up playing six times against the men.

Given her success rate against men, and the damage it might be doing to her confidence, that's probably four times too many.

When she starts next year on the LPGA Tour in February, Wie will have played only five times in a six-month stretch, four of those against the men.

What likely will keep her from joining the LPGA Tour now is her senior year of high school; Wie only played four times during the spring semester this year, and one of those weeks was spring break.

The downside would be giving up some appearance money.

Considering her total income this year was about $20 million, she can afford it. What she can't afford are more wipeouts.

TUMULTUOUS YEAR


During her first full professional season, Michelle Wie played seven men's tournaments - including three on the PGA Tour - with an average score of 75.07 in 15 rounds.

In May, she made her first cut against the men, when she became the first woman to make the cut on the Asian Tour at the SK Telecom Open.


A look at how the now-17-year-old fared on the major men's and women's tours in 2006:

PGA Tour LPGA Tour *
Events 3 7
Cuts made 0 7
Scoring avg. 76.4 70.78
Best finish - T2, Evian Masters
Earnings - $680,921

* Stats exclude the HSBC Women's World Match Play event, where she lost in the quarterfinals, 4&3 to Brittany Lincicome.

Sources: ESPN.com. lpga.com