Canceled show revived issue of how TV treats Jesus, Christians
Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Before memories fade about "The Book of Daniel" show, which NBC-TV canceled after only three weeks, it's worth pondering Hollywood's latest treatment of Jesus, Christians and the clergy.

Some liberal Episcopalians thought this drama (or was it satire?) might attract new churchgoers. Conservative Episcopalians said the series displayed how liberalism has corrupted their denomination. Some aimed boycotts at advertisers and NBC.

(Fresh from that fuss, NBC apparently dropped plans for Britney Spears to spoof Christian TV on "Will & Grace" by hosting a "Cruci-fixin's" cooking show. This hilarity would have aired on Holy Thursday as Christians commemorate the Last Supper on the eve of Jesus' crucifixion.)

The show portrayed Episcopal priest Daniel and his family and flock. Plots involved Daniel's addiction to painkillers, his daughter's pot-dealing and arrest, his wife's alcohol dependence, his son's promiscuity, his bishop father's adultery, his in-laws' criminality and a Roman Catholic priest's mob ties.

Homosexual characters were prominent - not surprising since the show's creator is a gay who had been raised Catholic. Daniel seemed ineffectual and parishioners came across as wealthy snobs or, in one instance, racist. The black maid was a thief. Priest and parishioners took the Lord's name in vain.

With "Daniel," reactions of particular interest appeared on two Web sites:

-www.blogofdaniel.com, operated by the liberal Washington, D.C., Episcopal diocese.

-www.titusonenine.classicalanglican.net, a must-read blog for church insiders from conservative priest Kendall Harmon. (The title refers to biblical Titus 1:9, which says bishops must "hold firm" to "sound doctrine" and "confute those who contradict it.")

Episcopalians smirked about NBC's gaffes in attire, terminology and other church details. Apparently, television exerts little effort on religious accuracy.

More significant, there was a striking religious divide over the program's device of having Jesus materialize regularly to chat with Daniel. Conservatives complained that NBC's Jesus was offensive fiction, unrelated to the morally commanding figure in the four Gospels. Liberals tended to enjoy Jesus' boys-will-be-boys, nonjudgmental attitude.

Some of the Daniel chatter from titusonenine:

"It was as if the character of Christ was there for comic relief.... It's all a gospel of self-help."

Jesus "acts like a wacky Dr. Phil."

"Jesus is nothing but a reflection of (Daniel's) own ego."

"This is how people see us: The Episcopal Church - just trying to get by with a cool and groovy 'relevant' Jesus."

"My wife and I think it portrays (the Episcopal Church and its) Jesus very truthfully, and unfortunately."

"Nothing about Jesus bearing our pain, shame, sin."

"I was amazed at the lack of respect or reverence for the holy Son of God. He is portrayed as if he were an old college pal.... To portray Jesus in this comedy as unable to heal, and tolerant to sin, is wrong."

Among the postings sent to the Washington diocese:

"I, for one, want to believe in a Jesus to whom I can talk and relate - just like the Jesus on this superb TV show."

"For all we know (Jesus) was the warm, loving, forgiving person portrayed in the show."

"I loved the Christ figure with his advice. I didn't find him at all namby pamby."

"Everything that Jesus said, I can imagine Jesus saying."

"The portrayal of Christ was the best thing about the show. He is shown as a Friend, a Confidant, an Adviser."

"If Jesus were too perfect and untouchable the conversations between him and Daniel wouldn't work as well."

"Jesus is a perfect listener."

"Jesus did seem a little dull, but maybe that's the point."

Christians are named for "a man whose single most important message was DO NOT JUDGE. Shame on you."

From an Episcopal priest: Jesus was "inclusive and loving," which "will drive the Fundies crazy."

But then there was this:

"As a Muslim, I am offended by this movie's depiction of our beloved Jesus Christ, may God's peace be upon him."

From the Tuesday, February 21, 2006 edition of the Augusta Chronicle
Reader Comments
Note: Comments are not edited and don't represent the views of The Augusta Chronicle. Please read our full comments policy. To report a post that may be inappropriate, click the icon.
Your display name is (change display name)
YOUR MESSAGE:
You have 1200 characters left.


advertisement

advertisement

TopJobs


Augusta-area Top Jobs
The Dialysis Access of Augusta is seeking a Fulltime RN for their interventional suite. Qualified candidates must have a current RN license, current certification in BLS and ACLS, and experience in ... (more)
Customer Service Reps Customer Service Representative Work with Soldiers. Major military consumer finance company seeks CSR's for Augusta, GA branch office. Full training provided. Excellent opportu... (more)
Dock Work FREIGHT HANDLER Call 706.868.6800 Operate forklift, pallet jack, secure freight inside trailers. >$10.50-12.50hr < PERMANENT POSITION w | this Great Nationwide Co. Pro Resources $... (more)


© 2009 The Augusta Chronicle|Terms of service|About our ads|Help|Contact us|Subscribe|Local business listings


shopping & services

What:
Where:



advertisement