The Tigers (28-12) led only 5-4 entering the seventh before scoring five times in the inning. Benedict added a run in the eighth and two in the ninth.
Jocquese Brunson drove in four runs to lead Benedict.
Luis Serrano went 3 for 5 with three RBI for Paine (19-22-1). William VanWinkle was 4 for 4 with an RBI.
John Hyer took the loss, allowing seven earned runs and 10 hits in six innings.