Scott MichauxSports columnist for The Augusta Chronicle. |

Michaux: Winston deserves to win the Heisman based on his on-field performance

  • Follow College

Once again, something other than football enters the Heisman Trophy debate.

On the surface, there is a clear-cut favorite when ballots for college football’s best player are due Monday. There is not one viable football-related reason not to vote for Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston – who has been about as perfect as a freshman can be since Day 1 of the 2013 season.

Of course, there is that year-old rape allegation that clouds the picture.

On Thursday, Florida’s state attorney Willie Meggs announced – during an uncomfortably upbeat press conference – that no charges would be filed against Winston stemming from an accusation made on Dec. 7, 2012, by another FSU student that he raped her after she had been drinking with friends at a local bar in Tallahassee, Fla. Meggs said that conflicting evidence and testimony from the accused would give the prosecution no “reasonable likelihood of conviction.” He said the investigation didn’t even reveal probable cause to arrest Winston, much less charge him with felony rape.

“The case is closed,” Meggs concluded.

This decision – conveniently issued two days before the top-ranked and undefeated Seminoles play Duke in the Atlantic Coast Conference championship game and four days before the Heisman ballots are due – elicited some very inappropriate elation in and around the Tallahassee courthouse in which it was delivered.

Six jean-short wearing fans ran around shirtless with “J-A-M-E-I-S” painted on their chests doing the tomahawk chop. Winston’s overly exuberant defense attorney tossed out the word “exonerated” even though investigators never said any such thing. The FSU quarterback was about as “exonerated” as Steelers’ quarterback Ben Roethlisberger was after a rape accusation in Milledgeville, Ga., ended up going nowhere.

Winston may never regain the public adulation (outside the Florida panhandle) that was growing up until a month ago before the oddly dormant rape allegation first surfaced. That he never agreed to even speak with investigators does nothing to enhance his lawyer’s insistence that “he did nothing wrong.”

But without any felony charges in the way, Winston is free to resume his life without hindrance. Whatever opinions this incident may have planted about his character have nothing to do with what he has and can accomplish on the football field.

The Heisman Trophy is a football award given to “the outstanding college football player whose performance best exhibits the pursuit of excellence with integrity.” There are people who cling to that “integrity” reference as some kind of morals clause, but there has been nothing verifiable demonstrated by Winston’s actions to preclude him winning the award.

And there is no doubt that Winston will win it – short of a complete meltdown failure against a Duke team that would be overmatched in every way by the Seminoles. When ballots are cast on Monday, Winston will be a landslide winner.

Winston has passed for 3,490 yards and 35 touchdowns on the fewest number of passing attempts (317) of anyone in the top 20 on the NCAA yardage charts. He leads the nation in passing efficiency (192.6), completing 68.8 percent of his attempts with only eight interceptions.

But what has stood out the most is his poise in the spotlight. Since his debut against Pitt – when he was nearly flawless completing 25 of 27 passes for 356 yards and four touchdowns – he’s been the consummate team leader. On the night of his toughest test on the road at No. 3 Clemson on Oct. 22, Winston delivered a pregame pep talk that was confident and carefree. Then he backed up his words with another landmark performance in a 51-14 blowout against fellow Heisman hopeful Tajh Boyd that erased all doubts about which was the best team and quarterback.

There was nothing not to like about the kid. He was charismatic and talented and the best player on a field of great players.

After that night, the Heisman was Winston’s to lose – and the rape allegations almost did that for him. Unless there was some resolution to the case before Monday’s deadline, there was zero chance of me casting a vote for him and risk honoring a rapist if he was later charged and found guilty.

In the past I have voted on the Heisman for players who smoked pot, players who violated underage drinking laws, players who had been involved in fights and players who were – for lack of any legal transgressions – simply jerks. I voted for both Reggie Bush and Cam Newton despite swirling rumors of major recruiting violations (Bush later got stripped of his Heisman).

None of these things, in my opinion, nullified what any of those players were able to accomplish on the football field in those seasons. Their sins were being young collegians who did some immature things. We all went to school with friends who did some of those same stupid things, or did some of them ourselves. It may not be something to be proud of, but part of growing up involves making mistakes and learning from them.

My personal code, however, draws the line at inflicting intentional harm upon others. Sexual assault ranks high atop the list of unforgiveable sins.

But Winston will not be charged for any crime. There may be suspicion but there’s no proof that he did anything wrong. Holding my suspicions against him would be just as wrong.

So despite all the unsavory sycophants doing the tomahawk chop and celebrating their blind allegiance with total disregard for anything but their football team, I’ll grit my teeth and write Winston’s name on my ballot.

I may not feel too proud or happy with that choice, but under a system of innocence until proven guilty it’s the right thing to do.

Comments (9) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
csrareader 12/08/13 - 08:45 am
"But without any felony

"But without any felony charges in the way, Winston is free to resume his life without hindrance. Whatever opinions this incident may have planted about his character have nothing to do with what he has and can accomplish on the football field."

Do you feel the same way about OJ? He was charged but found not guilty of trying to behead his ex-wife.

avidreader 12/08/13 - 09:55 am
Cheers to Michaux!

Your commentary is bold and decisive; no beating around the bush. Personally, I believe there's more to the Winston allegation than the public will ever know. However, as citizens we are taught and often reminded to respect our justice system and trust that innocent people will not be strong-armed in the courts. "Something fishy going on" does not constitute persecution.

And, as to CSRA's comment about O.J. -- I don't get the point, if there is one.

justthefacts 12/08/13 - 10:02 am
Other infractions

There is other evidence that Winston is not deserving, if Integrity is to be considered. It recently came out that he shot all the windows out of the dorm with BB guns. Some "booster" paid to replace them and it was overlooked. He was charged with stealing at a local Burger King. But, when someone explained to the owner that he would never sell another hamburger in Tallahassee if he pressed charges, the owner dropped the charges. If Integrity means anything, and I know it doesn't, give it Connor Shaw.

movingtoaugusta 12/08/13 - 10:34 am
Blah , Blah, Blah - Just the same old same old Blah, Blah, Blah

It is not the least bit surprising that losers dream up reasons that their guy didn't win, thereby justifying their overinflated opinion of themselves. Comparing Jameis to Roethlisberger is, well, sad. Saying that 19 year old college kids will be without faults, is naive. Expounding "facts" that are unsubstantiated is small ball. Go play the game as best you can, act like Vince Lombardy or Bear Bryant are watching and congratulate the winners.

Go the Dome!

Congratulations Jimbo, Jameis and the rest of the Noles. Now beat Auburn!

justthefacts 12/08/13 - 10:45 am
"Expounding "facts" that are unsubstantiated"

Yeah, that Sports Illustrated, always lying..right? That's OK, I realize that the end always justifies the means to some. They don't call it "free shoes university" for nothing. But, heck, look at Auburn's thieving QB. Classic matchup in some ways.

Grandpa Jones
Grandpa Jones 12/08/13 - 05:06 pm
Hypesman Trophy

Below is a chart from FoxSports after 10 games comparing top Heisman candidates. From the chart after 10 games this year, Manziel = the best quarterback and should be getting his second consecutive Heisman trophy over Winston.

But Winston will probably get the trophy because he is the new sensation on the scene. FSU finished the season undefeated and the Aggies = 4 losses (Like Manziel can help that the Aggies had a sorry defense. Blame the coaches for that one). Also, note how many teams that FSU played are still in the BCS Top 10 and BCS Top 25 versus the teams that the Aggies had to play??? LOL.

Total yards:

1. Manziel (3,924)
 2. Mariota (3,026)
 3. Winston (2,818)
 4. Petty (2,775)
 5. AJ (2,019)

Total yards per game:

1. Manziel (392.4)
 2. Petty (346.9) 
3. Mariota (336.2)
 4. Winston (313.1)
 5. AJ (224.3)

Total passing yards:

1. Manziel (3,313)
2. Winston (2,661)
3. Petty (2,657)
4. Mariota (2,531)
5. AJ (2,041)

Passing yards per game:

1. Petty (332.1)
 2. Manziel (331.3)
 3. Winston (295.7) 
4. Mariota (281)
 5. AJ (226.7)

Total rushing yards:

1. Manziel (611)
 2. Mariota (495)
 3. Winston (157)
 4. Petty (118)
 5. AJ (-22)

Rushing yards per game:

1. Manziel (61)
 2. Mariota (55)
 3. Winston (17)
 4. Petty (15)
 5. AJ (negative 2)

Total TDs:

1. Manziel (39) 
2. Mariota (31)
 3. Winston (29)
 3. Petty (29) 
5. AJ (19)

Passing TDs:

1. Manziel (31) 
2. Winston (26) 
3. Mariota (22)
 4. Petty (21)
 5. AJ (19)

Rushing TDs:

1. Mariota (9)
 2. Manziel (8)
 2. Petty (8)
 4. Winston (3)
 5. AJ (zero)

Avg. TDs per game:

1. Manziel (3.9)
 2. Petty (3.6)
 3. Mariota (3.4)
 4. Winston (3.2)
 5. AJ (2.1)

Completion percentage:

1. Manziel (230/315 = 73 percent)
 2. McCarron (159/229 = 69.4 percent)
 3. Winston (166/240 = 69.2 percent)
 4. Petty (135/202 = 66.8 percent)
 5. Mariota (164/259 = 63 percent)

Interception per pass attempt ratio:

1. Mariota ( 0/259 = 0)
 2. Petty ( 1/202 = 0.495 percent)
 3. AJ ( 3/229 = 1.31 percent) 
4. Winston ( 7/240 = 2.92 percent)
 5. Manziel ( 11/315 = 3.49 percent)

Grandpa Jones
Grandpa Jones 12/08/13 - 05:06 pm
Adjustment for playing time

For the people who will say that because of FSU were "blowing teams out" that Winston didn't get to play as much as Manziel, the below website article by Mike Knipe adjusts for playing time for Manziel and Winston:

Little Lamb
Little Lamb 12/08/13 - 08:50 pm

One should never award a Heisman Trophy to a freshman, even a red-shirted freshman. They need to put at least three seasons on the field to be considered.

Scott Michaux
Scott Michaux 12/09/13 - 07:06 pm
Several points

1) OJ? The very significant difference is that we all got to watch a very detailed and excruciating trial filled with all the same facts that were presented to the jury. One can reasonably disagree with the jury's decision in that case. We are not privy to all of the evidence in Winston's case.
2) Simply saying being in a BB gun fight with fellow students and filling a soda cup at Burger King hardly qualifies someone as a hardened criminal. That could have fit the general description of a lot of immature college students I knew and know.
3) There is a reason we don't vote for the Heisman Trophy after only 10 games in the season. I think those last two games made a pretty large difference in assessing Johnny Manziel.
4) How are the Winston and Roethlisberger situations not comparable? 2 prominent QBs accused of rape but not charged. Hmm.
5) It's given to the "most outstanding college player" not the "most outstanding upperclassman." Not a lifetime achievement award.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs