A trap for probationers

House Bill 837 is a needless gift to the private probation industry

  • Follow Editorials

There are a few bills from the 2014 Georgia General Assembly that Gov. Nathan Deal should refuse to sign.


House Bill 837 should be at the top of the list.

This bill, intended to reform Georgia’s thinly regulated private probation industry, does the opposite by giving the for-profit companies more authority and allowing them to shield more records from public scrutiny.

Critics of the legislation – count us among them – have called it a “gift” to the private probation industry, which has come under fire in recent years for abusive and heavy-handed tactics against the misdemeanor probationers some companies oversee.

Many of those complaints involved the local operations of Sentinel Offender Services, a firm at the center of a civil-rights lawsuit brought by low-income probationers who found themselves trapped in a cycle of debt because of their inability to pay fines, fees and surcharges.

Does that sound like extortion and indentured servitude? It does to us.

Worse, some probationers were unaware the company took out arrest warrants for nonpayment of fines and fees, even long after their original probation term expired.

Remember the term “double-secret probation” from the movie Animal House? This is double-secret probation in real life, and on a frightening scale.

The practice is perplexing to say the least, considering the U.S. Supreme Court ruled decades ago that a person cannot be jailed simply for being too poor to pay a fine.

Sadly, the safeguards and accountability provisions that could have prevented these tactics were stripped from H.B. 837 once it moved to the Senate’s noncivil Judiciary Committee, led by Sen. Jesse Stone, R-Waynesboro.

Stone also happens to be one of two candidates to fill a State Court judgeship in Burke County, which contracts with CSRA Probation Services, a for-profit probation firm. Less than a week before Stone’s committee watered down H.B. 837, CSRA Probation’s owner wrote Stone a letter of recommendation for the judgeship.

Also, three days before the start of the legislative session, Stone received his single-largest campaign contribution from the Georgia Association of Professional Bondsmen. During the session, Stone sponsored a bill that increases the fees companies charge to post bonds, which generally are set by judges.

Stone says he receives contributions from numerous groups, and that there is no quid pro quo.

“I don’t see these as conflicts of interest,” he said with a straight face.

Regardless, his actions enable private corporations to extend probation sentences for nonpayment of fines and fees as well as supervise a variety of fee-based electronic monitoring services.

Exactly how much these companies can collect – and even the number of people they supervise – can become secret if the bill becomes law.

The organization Human Rights Watch estimates Georgia’s private probation industry generated $40 million in revenue last year.

Privatization usually improves efficiency and reduces the taxpayers’ burden, and generally we are in favor of it. But placing judicial powers in the hands of a for-profit corporation with the authority to incarcerate requires strong legislation to ensure that some of society’s most marginalized citizens will not be unfairly exploited.

H.B. 837 is not that legislation, and Gov. Deal should keep his signature off it.

Comments (4) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
specsta
8886
Points
specsta 04/23/14 - 02:42 am
5
0
Veto The Bill

ACES, on extremely rare occasions, you guys are right on target.

This is one of those times.

Riverman1
120948
Points
Riverman1 04/23/14 - 05:05 am
6
0
When Bluto Eats Keep Your Hands and Feet Out of the Way

The whole private probation industry is a way to squeeze more than fines out of these people. Someone placed on probation with one of these companies ends up paying a fortune. It's a shakedown operation that's legal. Unfortunately, the money reaches all levels of the judicial system as we see with Jesse Stone. There's no way Deal won't sign the bill. There's too much money being passed out coming from the extortion of these poor people without influence. Keep your hands and feet out of the reach of the private probation companies when they are hungry.

dichotomy
46927
Points
dichotomy 04/23/14 - 09:02 am
4
0
VETO this bill Gov. Deal. WAY

VETO this bill Gov. Deal. WAY too much money and political patronage changed hands to get this bill rammed through. Almost everyone I know thinks that the abuses that have gone on from these private probation companies are WRONG, ILLEGAL, IMMORAL, and UNCONSTITIONAL.

Of course, if our legislators feel that contracting out THIS PORTION of the criminal justice system is such a good idea and a big money saver, WHY NOT JUST GO AHEAD AND CONTRACT OUT ALL OF OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT AND COURT SYSTEM. Let's just go ahead and abdicate ALL government responsibility for the criminal justice system to private mercenary cops and contract judges and prosecutors. I'm sure we could save a ton of money and there would be a lot more contractor BRIBERY MONEY to pass around to our lawmakers.

Fiat_Lux
20038
Points
Fiat_Lux 04/23/14 - 10:01 am
2
1
Just what the heck can anyone do about this?

Deal couldn't care less about Georgians and it's quite clear that state legislators and judges like the nefarious Mr. Stone are concerned with the thickness of their wallets and the reach of their influence.

I don't believe the voters have much say in this kind of treachery--except to stay on the right side of the law whenever possible. Of course, nowadays legislation is flying through approvals that is quite immoral, so good and responsible citizens may soon find themselves under scrutiny for standing up in defense of traditional moral and social values.

jimmymac
68478
Points
jimmymac 04/24/14 - 05:11 pm
0
0
Comments
Unpublished

I agree with all comments and the governor should do the right thing and veto the bill. I wonder how many palms were greased by the private probation industry?

Back to Top
loading...
Search Augusta jobs