What to listen for tonight

Don't believe your eyes -- use your ears to search for substance in debate

  • Follow Editorials

Who do you think would win in a debate between columnist George Will and comedian Jon Stewart?

It probably depends on whether you’re watching it or reading the transcript; whether you’re actually scoring the arguments or listening for the laugh lines.

That fact may also color how you view tonight’s ultra-important debate between presidential candidates Barack Obama and Mitt Romney.

Given the history of these two campaigners, it’s fair to expect that Mr. Romney will come off like your dad’s accountant – serious and knowledgeable, which hasn’t sold well in the television era – and for Mr. Obama to be light on substance and heavy on platitudes and whimsy, which plays well in front of live audiences.

This, in an election that will determine the future of this country.

Also, given presidential debate lore, what will be remembered likely won’t be either candidate’s command of the facts or their vision for the future, but their one-liners. And their comportment – did they sigh a lot? did they look at their watches? did they sweat? did they seem nice? – will determine the pundits’ decisions on who “won.”

This isn’t a game, though. It’s not a boxing match where the head and body blows are tabulated. This is an election to determine who will lead the most powerful nation on Earth. Should it be seen as a win or a loss for a man, based upon how good he looked or how bad he made the other guy look? Or should it be a way for Americans to determine which candidate’s vision has a better chance of lifting the nation out of its chronic doldrums?

There can be little doubt that George Will is the greater intellect. But could he “win” a debate against a snarky comedian in today’s America?

You can pretty much score the Romney-Obama debate beforehand: If we’re judging it by reason, fact and the record of the incumbent, Romney wins. If we’re judging it by charm, glibness and how he makes you feel, it’s Obama’s to lose.

Reason tells you that the current president is spending future generations to oblivion with nothing to show for it; that his health-care law is actually increasing premiums instead of reducing them; that all manner of taxes will strike a weakened America like a meteor next year; that this president’s anti-business, pro-government policies aren’t helping (and how could they?); and that his foreign policy initiatives are in flames.

Reason also makes you wonder: Would the country and its left-wing intelligentsia be so wholly silent about the continued carnage in Afghanistan were this a Republican president? Or would Cindy Sheehan be camped out as she was at Bush’s ranch?

It’s a good bet, though, that reason won’t decide either this debate outcome or the election’s. And that the Obama camp is banking on it.

Other media outlets may tell you what to watch for tonight. What you should be thinking about, in our view, is what to listen for.

Our hearty recommendation: substance.

Comments (26) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
KSL 10/03/12 - 07:27 pm
Do you have stats on the

Do you have stats on the number of Catholics who give him credence?

ultrarnr 10/03/12 - 07:36 pm
On a totally different note

For all of those complaining about the current energy policies. This si from Bloomberg

Oil fell to a two-month low in New York after the government reported that U.S. crude production climbed to the highest level in more than 15 years and fuel consumption decreased.
Oil futures dropped 4.1 percent after the Energy Department said crude output rose 11,000 barrels a day to 6.52 million last week, the most since December 1996. Total fuel demand fell 0.3 percent to 18.3 million barrels a day in the four weeks ended Sept. 28, the lowest level since April. Crude and distillate stockpiles declined as gasoline supplies rose.

LillyfromtheMills 10/03/12 - 08:54 pm
Yea, what KSL said.

Yea, what KSL said.

shrimp for breakfast
shrimp for breakfast 10/04/12 - 12:13 am
They were both lousy

They have all these ideas and yet don't tell us how they will work. Are you telling me that out of all the people in this country Mitt Romney is the best the Republicans could do? My goodness there has got to be a decent Presidential candidate out there somewhere!

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
AU professor doing research on Gulf War health disparities
An Augusta University professor is being funded to do research on the health disparities of female veterans involved in the first Gulf War compared to their male counterparts.