A good intention misfires

Gun buyback misses target of making streets safer

  • Follow Editorials

Niki Watson doesn’t even live here anymore. But she went miles out of her way to help her hometown recently.

An Augusta native and Westside High School graduate, she didn’t like the Augusta news she was getting in Queens, N.Y. – particularly the shootings of people her age here.

“I had to do something,” she said.

We don’t want to temper her enthusiasm. We need more of it.

But gun violence is a very real problem that requires a realistic approach to solve. And there’s absolutely no reason to believe the gun buyback she staged Aug. 4 at Antioch Baptist Church will have done a thing to make the streets safer.

Evidence from such programs around the country indicates clearly that it’s mostly a public relations gimmick for shrewd politicians to make themselves look good.

“That’s what it is,” one local law enforcement expert told us.

“In truth,” the Los Angeles Times wrote after such a buyback there in 2009, “studies of municipal gun buyback programs have never turned up a shred of evidence that they reduce firearm violence. ... It’s safe to say that there are millions of guns hereabout. The 1,700 turned in Saturday did not significantly reduce the number.

“What’s more, the guns that tend to be surrendered are very seldom the ones used by criminals. They are usually old, broken weapons turned in by older people who would rather have a $100 gift certificate to
buy groceries (the premium offered Saturday to those who brought in guns) than a rusted revolver.”

In the case of the Aug. 4 buyback here, participants were given $70 gift cards in return for bringing in guns, no questions asked.

It appears for all the world as if what Ms. Watson got – some 22 guns – were the wrong guns from the wrong people.

“Organizers expected to see mostly young black men, but more women, older people and whites turned in guns than they expected,” our news story reported.

It’s a very safe bet the guns weren’t being used in crime – and many might never have been used for any other reason. Gun buyback programs are a great opportunity for folks to turn unwanted, worthless,
even unusable guns into cash – in many cases much more
cash than the gun might be worth.

Our law enforcement expert said no thug is going to cash in a $600 firearm for a $70 gift card.

So far, none of the guns turned in Aug. 4 have turned up as having been stolen, either.

Again, we appreciate Ms. Watson’s drive and civic-mindedness, including her willingness to cut five personal checks when the gift cards ran out. Her passion is utterly disarming.

Unfortunately, much more so than a gun buyback.

Comments (3) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Craig Spinks
Craig Spinks 08/11/12 - 01:20 am
Our streets and our public schools will be safer places when...

we appreciate that REAL MEN love and care for their children.

Riverman1 08/11/12 - 06:07 am
Of Course PR Stunts Are Rarely Effective

Remember Operation Augusta Ink when I noted it was a bad idea to have a continuing program that actually encouraged crime? Few agreed with me except one Morris Co. reporter who also saw the flaw in the program. The program was finally called off because of the increased crime it promoted.

Crooks will steal guns and property to sell when there is a buyer. If this young lady had actually had the money to pay for the guns (which she didn't) it would have eventually turned into a matter of crooks finding guns to sell, no matter how they got them.

In addition, I wouldn't allow a private person to undertake such a program of obtaining contributions of gift cards for the buyback without carefull accounting and precise control of what happens to all the guns. There was no accountability with this amateur attempt. I am a skeptic and trust no one.

soapy_725 08/11/12 - 09:18 am
Zeal for Good.....

Without knowledge and wisdom. A standard human character flaw. Some desire to change the world, rather than introduce people to the only one who can truly change lives. you must change the heart to affect lawless behavior. we sin because we are sinners.

scoopdedoop64 08/11/12 - 09:51 pm
Had the Same Thought

When I first read the story about the guns buy back and how this young lady was investing her time and money I could not help admire her and certainly do agree that we must work to get guns out of the hands of criminals. Yet, her approach is just not going to do much to change the situation. The only guns she gets are the legal ones and not the criminals ready to turn over a new leaf for a gift card. Bless her heart for her efforts but right now its best we keep our guns because the criminals are not turning theirs in yet.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs