Coaches divided on icing kickers

Attempting to ice kickers before a key field goal is almost as old as goal posts. Seahawks coach Mike Holmgren, until last year a member of the league's competition committee, doesn't do it.


And he doesn't like the trend of coaches calling timeouts just before snaps on field goals.

He talked to league officiating chief Mike Perreira this week after Buffalo called time as Dallas was about to snap on rookie Nick Folk's winning field-goal attempt. The Bills were granted the timeout before the kick sailed through the uprights. Folk then boomed his second try from 53 yards to win the game Monday night anyway.

"I don't like the way that looks or how it is ... not right when the ball is snapped," said Holmgren, who is something of a traditionalist and in his 16th year as an NFL head coach. "The idea of a coach being able to call a timeout, which is relatively new - we put that in two or three years ago - I know the rule wasn't intended to do that."

Should there be an even newer rule? Holmgren said he didn't know the best solution.

Colts coach Tony Dungy has no intention of following the trend, either.

"Are you going to say, 'Hey, take a practice free throw or hey, take that practice putt from 10 feet away first,'" he said. "I think it's a dumb play. I don't think the rule needs to be changed. I think most people in that situation want to take a timeout, but you don't want the guy taking a practice kick."

The late timeouts have produced mixed results this season.

Denver's Mike Shanahan used it to throw off Oakland's Sebastian Janikowski, giving the Broncos an opportunity to win the game minutes later on Jason Elam's field goal in Week 2. The next week, Oakland coach Lane Kiffin used it successfully against Cleveland's Phil Dawson. The Raiders blocked the kick to preserve a 26-24 victory.

On Monday night, Folk beat Buffalo.

But Dungy believes waiting to call the timeout actually gives the kicker an advantage.

"I think it's a better strategy to call it before they snap the ball and not let them figure out how the wind is blowing or whatever," Dungy said.

One option would prohibit timeouts by the defense on field goals after a team is set in its kicking formation.

"Most coaches like the rule where they can call the timeout on the sideline, for a normal thing. I hope there's some way to modify this for the kicking game," Holmgren said.

"I'll tell you right now, I'm not going to do that. I don't like it."



Chiefs won’t have Smith, pair of running backs for Sunday

Chiefs coach Andy Reid had just declared Alex Smith out with a head injury, announced Jamaal Charles was undergoing knee surgery and revealed that... Read more

Panthers’ Newton talks over concerns with Goodell

Cam Newton got the phone call he wanted.

NFL commissioner Roger Goodell spoke via telephone with Newton about the Carolina quarterback's... Read more