News |   Obits |   Sports |   Business |   Opinion |   Things to Do |   Life |   Blogs |   Photos |   Video |   Data |   Jobs |   Homes |   Autos |   Buy/Sell


US high court sends back to South Carolina child custody case

  • Follow Metro

CHARLESTON, S.C. — The U.S. Supreme Court is pushing South Carolina courts to quickly take up a custody case that will decide whether a Native American girl’s life will be with her biological father in Oklahoma or the South Carolina couple who adopted her.

FILE/ASSOCIATED PRESS
After Tuesday’s ruling, a 3-year-old girl named Veronica still doesn’t know where she will live.

A divided high court ruled Tuesday that federal law doesn’t require that the girl, Veronica, stay with her biological father, but also doesn’t give her adoptive parents immediate custody of the 3-year-old child.

The court issued an order Friday speeding up the case being sent back to South Carolina’s Supreme Court.

Melanie and Matt Capo­bianco of James Island had lost in South Carolina courts before the nation’s highest court ruled that the Indian Child Welfare Act didn’t apply in the case because the biological father never had custody of the child and abandoned her before birth.

“Some people thought we should just go get another child,” Melanie Capobianco told The Post and Courier of Charleston. “It’s not like she’s just any child. We love her.”

Dusten Brown, a member of the Cherokee Nation, invoked the federal law to stop the adoption arranged by the girl’s non-Indian mother when she was pregnant. The Capobiancos were present at Veronica’s birth in Oklahoma. Brown had never met his daughter and, after the mother rebuffed his marriage proposal, played no role during the pregnancy and paid no child support.

But when Brown found out Veronica was going to be adopted, he objected and said the law favored the girl living with him and growing up with tribal traditions.

South Carolina courts sent Ve­ronica back to Oklahoma at the end of 2011, even though she had lived with the Capo­biancos for the first 27 months of her life.

“I’m going to keep fighting,” Brown told the newspaper.

The state Supreme Court’s first task will be finalizing the Capobiancos’ adoption. Their most likely approach is that the justices will send the case back to Charleston County Family Court, where judges would be ordered to abide by the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision, reconsider the facts and decide on the adoption petition, said John Nichols, who represented Brown before the state Su­preme Court.

“We are in uncharted waters,” Nichols said. “We have been from the very beginning. The map is still not complete.”

Brown’s role in Veronica’s life now is something Uni­versity of South Carolina law professor Marcia Zug thinks cannot be ignored. The family with custody is often given preference in state custody proceedings. Now the Capobiancos must argue the opposite of their position in state court, that taking Veronica from the home she knew since birth might stunt her development and cause psychological problems.

“At this age, she probably doesn’t remember who they are,” Zug said. “It’s not reuniting her with a family she’s missing. It’s taking her away from the only family she knows.”

Comments (1) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
TruthJusticeFaithHope
216
Points
TruthJusticeFaithHope 07/01/13 - 09:47 am
0
0
Veronica must stay with the adoptive par

From what is published, Veronica must stay with the adoptive parents.

The child's needs first
Brown never wanted or attempted to obtain custody when he could and should have.
Brown never even got to know Veronica.
Brown never helped support Veronica.
Children are not property.
But Indian tribes have power ... I hope the SC Supreme Court does the correct thing... The child's needs first !

Back to Top

Top headlines

Property tax increase OK'd

Augusta commissioners broke a seven-year trend Wednesday and agreed 7-0 to raise property taxes by 1.75 mills to cover a deficit and provide employees a small bonus.
Search Augusta jobs