In a case to be argued before the high court today, Michael Turner contends that poor people facing time behind bars for missing payments have a constitutional right to an attorney at taxpayer expense. Florida, Maine, New Hampshire and Ohio are the other states where deadbeat parents are not automatically given a lawyer in such cases.
By at least one estimate, hundreds of people a year in those states do time for not paying child support -- a practice some advocates say penalizes both parent and child.
Opponents say providing lawyers would prove costly and clog up an already cumbersome legal process and that deadbeats already control their own destinies: If they pay, they go free.
In its ruling against Tucker, the South Carolina Supreme Court said a delinquent dad holds "the keys to his cell because he may end the imprisonment" by paying at least some of what is owed.