Health Care More | | | Editor

Group says Romney plan would increase uninsured

More uninsured would be result, group predicts

Tuesday, Oct. 2, 2012 12:53 AM
Last updated Thursday, July 11, 2013 2:06 PM
  • Follow Health

Not only would his plan to repeal President Obama’s health care overhaul increase the number of uninsured in the future, but Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney’s health insurance proposals would also add 12 million more to the uninsured than doing nothing, a group said Monday.

The private nonpartisan Com­mon­wealth Fund re­leased its analysis of the im­pact of the Affordable Care Act, Romney’s proposals and what would happen if nothing were done at all.

They are “distinctly different approaches” under Rom­ney and Obama, Com­mon­wealth Presi­dent Karen Davis said.

The group, which advocates for better health care, par­ticularly for the poor, said the current health reform will reduce the number of uninsured in 2022 by 32.9 million, leaving 27.1 million still without insurance. That num­ber would be 60 million if nothing were done but would increase to 72 million un­der Romney’s proposals, the group said, primarily be­cause of Romney’s idea to shift federal Medicaid fund­ing into a block grant to states.
In Commonwealth’s analysis, nearly 2.3 million Georgians – 25 percent – would be uninsured if nothing is done, versus 930,000 under the Affordable Care Act and more than 2.5 million under Romney’s proposals. In South Carolina, 1.1 million – 27.7 percent – would be uninsured if the status quo continued, while 420,000 would be uninsured if the Affordable Care Act continues and 1.27 million would be uninsured under the Romney plan.

Commonwealth made a number of assumptions in its analysis in part because the Romney campaign has not specified exactly what it would do in many health care issues, including the conversion of Medicaid to block grants to the states. The analysis assumed that would result in an overall reduction in federal funding that states would respond to equally by cutting costs such as provider reimbursement and reducing eligibility.

“If they could find more ways of cutting that cost and less eligibility cuts, then the uninsured numbers that we have would likely be lower,” said Sara Collins, Commonwealth’s vice president of affordable health insurance. In most states, however, Medicaid costs and payments are already low, so further reductions there might be difficult to pull off, she said.

“We felt this was a reasonable set of assumptions about how states would respond to the block grants,” Collins said.

Romney has proposed capping non-economic damages in malpractice cases and innovation grants for nonlitigation alternatives to lawsuits, something the health care overhaul didn’t address, Davis said.

“Most experts really think it was an omission (from the health care law) not to address the issue of medical liability, particularly in the context of efforts to improve patient safety,” she said.

Other Romney proposals appear to have a mixed benefit in the analysis.

He proposes ending tax discrimination against people who buy individual health care policies compared with those who get them through an employer, and he wants to allow insurance companies to sell across state lines.

Romney would also urge small businesses to band together through trade groups and other associations to purchase insurance as a group, but he has not spelled out specifically how he would do it, according to the analysis. That would be helpful to businesses with younger, healthier workers but might be present problems for those with older workers, according to the analysis.

Comments (1) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
rmwhitley 10/02/12 - 10:15 am
Commonwealth Fund

is nonpartisan my ---!

lovingthesouth72 10/02/12 - 11:05 am
Hog wash. When more people

Hog wash. When more people get jobs, thanks to Romeny's 5 step plan to creat jobs and strenghten the economy, then more people will have insurance. Medicaid/mericare will still remain for those that need it. But with more people able to get jobs, less people will need these programs. Good stuff people! Real hope for this country is on it's way once we change the man in the White House!! Romney/Ryan 2012!!!

MarinerMan 10/02/12 - 01:42 pm
And I'm sure the

And I'm sure the "assumptions" were ALWAYS on the negative side of the balance sheet. A block grant of Federal funds would allow the states to increase the Medicaid rolls. And I agree with 'lovingthesouth72' there will be more people working under Romney, versus the tons of jobs our "Community Organizer" has not created.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs