Supercomputer Watson learns medicine

  • Follow Health

ATLANTA — It vanquished the human champions on the quiz show Jeopardy and now the supercomputer Watson is turning to medicine, one of the IBM developers said Friday. One activist argues that in a number of years Watson and computers like it could spark a debate about whether human doctors are needed at all.

Back | Next
Jeopardy contestants Ken Jennings (left) and Brad Rutter compete with Watson on the show. The supercomputer can access 200 million pages of text in about three seconds.  FILE/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Jeopardy contestants Ken Jennings (left) and Brad Rutter compete with Watson on the show. The supercomputer can access 200 million pages of text in about three seconds.

Speaking to the Health Jour­nal­ism 2012 convention of the As­so­ciation of Health Care Jour­­nalists, IBM Chief Medical Sci­entist Martin Kohn said Watson had to learn how to actually understand the English language, not just recognize words, in order to succeed on the show. It can access 200 million pages of text in about three seconds, then uses hundreds of algorithms to analyze the evidence and gauge the confidence it has in the answer.

On Jeopardy, for instance, Watson answered only when it had a response above a certain confidence threshold and the supercomputer’s biggest blunder – answering “Toronto” when asked to name a U.S. city with two airports – came during Final Jeopardy when it had to answer even though it had little confidence in the response, Kohn said.

It will be a little different with medicine and trying to reach a diagnosis.

“There may not be one answer,” Kohn said. And in fact, IBM is not pushing Watson as a diagnosis maker.

“Watson doesn’t make decisions for you,” Kohn said. The results Watson would give back would be more along the lines of “these are the things you ought to think about,” Kohn said. “It really is clinical decision support.”

But that’s not what self-described “patient hacktivist” Fred Trotter sees as the end result of artificial intelligence in medicine.

“Artificial intelligence in health care will be the most important force in diagnosis,” he said.

The biggest obstacle right now is the lack of electronic health records and a lack of access to those records by patients to correct what Trotter said is probably wrong or misleading information. Kohn concedes that machines like Watson would only be as good as the information it got from the records.

Trotter foresees a time when the physician will be a “hybrid” linked into a computer like Watson during the patient visit, interfacing with both to aid diagnosis. And Kohn could foresee patients accessing Watson directly to get personalized suggestions on their care.

“Going forward, you’re going to have to make more and more decisions with your (health care) team,” he said.

But Trotter can see years down the road an argument springing up: “Why are we using doctors?” he asked, with the supercomputers around.

Comments (3) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Craig Spinks
Craig Spinks 04/21/12 - 02:55 am
Many hospitals and other

Many hospitals and other health service enterprises including those formerly known as medical practices will work to thwart medical information sharing as a market-protection ploy.

Craig Spinks
Craig Spinks 04/21/12 - 02:56 am
Watson, Please turn your


Please turn your focus to public education after you have mastered your medical efforts.

itsanotherday1 04/21/12 - 01:51 pm
Dittos and dittos Craig. I'm

Dittos and dittos Craig. I'm excited at the prospect of supercomputer assisted treatment.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
Crash kills Augusta man, 57
The coroner says an autopsy is planned, possibly Friday, into the death of an Augusta man killed Wednesday night in a single-car accident.