Opponent assails Rep. Barrow constituent messages

  • Follow Elections

A Republican candidate has blasted John Barrow because he reportedly sent constituents more tax-paid messages than any other U.S. House member.

Gannett News Service said the Georgia Democrat whose 12th District represents part of the Augusta area, sent 35.7 million communications in 2009.

Gannett said those missives - such as mailings, phone calls, radio and print ads - cost $264,591, tops for Georgia's 13 House members.

In contrast, Republican Jack Kingston, Chatham County's other House member, spent $37,823 - 11th in the Georgia delegation.

The communications, monitored by a House committee that is supposed to weed out messages that are excessively self-promoting, are legal.

But in election years, they draw sharp criticism from challengers who consider them tax-subsidized campaigning.

This year, Barrow is drawing fire from Ray McKinney, one of four Republicans seeking the GOP nomination in Barrow's 12th Congressional District.

The Lyons resident called Barrow's spending "out of control and a waste of taxpayer dollars."

"Barrow," he added, "is famous around the country now ... but unfortunately for the wrong reason - excessive spending.

"Congressional approval ratings are the lowest they've ever been because people are sick and tired of ... unnecessary spending."

McKinney proposed slashing the costs of such communications by sending them only to people who request them.

Barrow spokeswoman Jane Brodsky did not dispute the accuracy of the Gannett compilation.

But Brodsky said communicating with constituents is a critical part of Barrow's job.

"He's in his district almost every weekend holding job fairs, health forums, veterans meetings, energy expos, town hall meetings and other events," she said.

"These announcements let people know about them. People come up and thank him."

Brodsky said she's not surprised he spent more than other Georgia congressmen.

"There are 22 counties in the district, and many communities have their own stations and newspapers. You can't reach everyone with just one of them."

She says the way the number of communications is calculated can be misleading.

For example, she said, an ad that runs four times in a 10,000-circulation newspaper must be reported as 40,000 communications.

She acknowledged that it seems "remarkable" that Barrow reported sending more than any other congressman.

But she said the House has a new reporting system and that she isn't sure how well it monitors reports for consistency.

Kyle Anderson, a spokesman for the House Administration Committee, did not return two phone calls made to seek comment.

University of Georgia political science professor Charles Bullock said sending such messages is a traditional perk of sitting members. And it's politically smart for Barrow to do so extensively, Bullock added.

"It's something incumbents do, and it's something constituents expect," he said.

Members have lost because voters thought they seldom heard from them, but not because voters heard too much from them, Bullock said.

Aside from providing useful information, he said, announcements get a congressman's name out.

"Year after year," he said, "you develop name familiarity even if people glance them and toss them. And people are more likely to vote for you than someone they never heard of."

In terms of money spent, Barrow did not make the top 10 nationally, Gannett said. No. 1 was Dina Titus, D-Nev., who shelled out $470,059.

In all, Gannett said, House members spent more than $45 million last year - up from $20 million in 2007.

McKinney lamented that trend.

"Communication with constituents is a necessary function," he said. "... But it shouldn't cost more than a quarter million dollars. We need to be smarter than that."

Comments (4) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
johnston.cliff 05/19/10 - 05:50 am
So informing constituents and

So informing constituents and notifying them of town hall meetings is a bad thing? While I prefer a more conservative representative, the people in Barrow's district seem to prefer him. This article seems to be notify us of several people barking up the wrong tree.

afadel 05/19/10 - 06:14 am
How about voting for billions

How about voting for billions for useless wars? This criticism directed at Dr. Broun is unwarranted. He deserves criticism for a lot of other things.

Little Lamb
Little Lamb 05/19/10 - 08:52 am
Wow! Gannett News Service

Wow! Gannett News Service said:

In all, House members spent more than $45 million last year - up from $20 million in 2007. Ray McKinney lamented that trend, "Communication with constituents is a necessary function, but it shouldn't cost more than a quarter million dollars. We need to be smarter than that."

How much will it be by 2012?

CoastalDawg 05/19/10 - 11:13 am
IF that is the only thing

IF that is the only thing that Ray McKinney has as his campaign foundation, he needs to save his money. I have issues with John Barrow, one that he proudly boasted of voting for the bailout money, but he has voted his constituent's wishes during the health care debacle - he voted against it because it continued to contain language detrimental to us. The blacks int he district have risen up against him for that, turning it into a racial issue when it clearly was not. Although he never had a town hall meeting in Savannah proper during last summer when the health non-care debate was so hot, he does inform his constituents of meetings and other things by mail and by telephone calls, although they show an ID that I and many others ignore because we believe them to be from telemarketers. John Barrow is not your "typical" Democrat, enthralled by everything that our president puts forth, but again, this is a might weak challenge from Ray McKinney. The Republicans won't gain that seat with Ray McKinney as the candidate.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
Early voting in Augusta-area shows increase
Area early voting numbers are dwarfing turnout four years ago, particularly in Republican-leaning Columbia County, and forecast apossible record voting year for the Augusta area.