Government

More News | | | Editor

Salary savings marginal in Augusta government reorganization, analysis shows

  • Follow Government

Intended to flatten management structure and reduce payroll, an ongoing reorganization of Augusta government in the works since late 2010 hasn’t reduced overall salaries by much, an analysis by The Augusta Chronicle has found.

Overall, Augusta government staffing went from 2,772 employees at the start of 2011 to 2,437 in January 2012.

Despite 335 fewer positions on the payroll, salary costs dropped by only 1.3 percent, going from around $91.32 million to nearly $90.13 million this year.

City Administrator Fred Russell said the plan could reduce annual payroll costs by about $2 million when he unveiled plans to reorganize city government in early 2011. A year later, total salaries are down by just more than $1.19 million.

When Russell surprised Augusta commissioners last summer by awarding 44 hefty pay increases – several of them greater than 40 percent – to select engineering, environmental services, finance, recreation and utilities managers, he explained that each had taken on more work and additional supervisory duties under the reorganization and the higher pay would actually create savings.

The savings has yet to surface in personnel costs, however. According to The Chronicle’s analysis, the only departments where total salaries noticeably decreased over the past year, among departments that were not merged with others or outsourced, were animal control, the library and Augusta Regional Airport.

Since the beginning of 2011, 87 employees have had raises of 10 percent or more. Ten pay increases of more than 12 percent awarded in Engineering amounted to greater than $111,500. Fourteen pay raises in Recreation, Parks and Facilities grew the payroll by $90,521. The lone employee left in transit received a 53 percent pay increase.

Transit was outsourced last year and 69 of its 70 positions went to the private sector, although the city still pays Mobility Transit to run the service.

Reorganized to take in building and grounds maintenance, Augusta Recreation, Parks and Facilities managed to shed 16 positions over the year, but the department’s total salaries grew by more than $1.82 million, a 52 percent increase.

Most departments retained about the same number of personnel in 2012 as they had in 2011. Total department salaries still rose slightly, however, as most employees who had gone without a raise for several years and lost three days’ pay last year because of furlough reduction got a $500 raise this year from the commission.

The changes, though slight, are “part of what I was directed to do, to make sure we’re getting the best bang for the buck,” Russell said. “The telling aspect is, at what level do we want to maintain services? It’s always a give and take.”

Mayor Pro Tem Joe Bowles, a proponent of restructuring the government and outsourcing city tasks, called the slight payroll reduction “a very slow start” to a necessary process.

“It’s been delayed. We can’t get consensus of the commission to make the necessary cuts. Every time we try to streamline or hire a private manager, we’re racists, bigots or ending the federal government, and we’ve only done two: transit and the golf course.”

Commissioner Jerry Brig­ham said the reductions would save the city money in the long term.

“How much more money would those positions save over this year, and the year after that? That’s where the savings is,” he said.

The commissioner who’s called himself “nitpicker-in-chief” said he would prefer to analyze the data himself but was optimistic after last week’s commission retreat, where the group agreed to hire an efficiency expert.

“I’m hoping if we get this efficiency study done it will tell us what’s going on,” Commissioner Bill Lockett said. “Someone with the professional expertise (can) come in and give this government an unbiased look, without any internal influences.”

AUGUSTA CITY WORKERS’ SALARIES
 20122011
Average city salary$36,983$32,967
Employees earning more than $120,000119
Earning more than $100,0002321
LARGEST CITY DEPARTMENTS IN 2012
 EMPLOYEESTOTAL SALARIES
Richmond County Sheriff711$26.16 million
Augusta Fire Department312$12.58 million
Augusta Utilities258$8.44 million
Recreation, Parks & Facilities169$5.33 million
Engineering111$3.87 million
HOW THE SALARY ANALYSIS WAS DONE

While other area cities and counties responded quickly to open records requests for employee position and salary data, The Augusta Chronicle had to piece together human resources records from the City of Augusta with individual department organizational charts to get an accurate picture of its staffing.

In many instances, employees were classified as working in departments that no longer exist.

“Public Works,” for example, hasn’t existed for nearly seven years, since numerous city maintenance functions were split off from the Engineering department then under former director Teresa Smith.

Those employees were moved into Public Services, a department eliminated last year in the ongoing reorganization of city departments.

Lacking information about where many of the some 2,673 staffers included in the database actually work, The Chronicle requested departmental organizational charts from Human Resources Manager Robby Burns.

Despite a requirement in the city’s new personnel manual that each department file an organizational chart with the human resources department before any reclassification or reorganization of personnel, the charts were not on file with HR at the time The Chronicle requested them Jan. 23.

Burns obtained and provided charts from the reorganized Recreation, Parks and Facilities and Environmental Services departments. Utilities Director Tom Wiedmeier provided an up-to-date Utilities spreadsheet a few days later.

Engineering Director Abie Ladson, however, refused to release his department’s structure, citing an upcoming commission meeting where several budget cuts affecting his department might be rescinded.

Ladson, whose department’s top staffers were among the first to receive raises last year for taking on additional duties under the reorganization, said he had no up-to-date organizational chart and would not release one.

Human Resources has lost several employees because of resignation or termination over the past year, including former HR Director Rod Powell, although at least two of the former employees remain on the payroll, according to HR records.

Deputy Administrator Bill Shanahan has served as acting HR director for several months, and the city is looking to outsource the department to Automatic Data Processing, an HR firm that operates a solution center in Augusta.

– Sand Hodson and Susan McCord, staff writers

Comments (8) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
mrducks
59
Points
mrducks 02/18/12 - 06:17 pm
0
0
Fred Russell, and all
Unpublished

Fred Russell, and all commissioners, need to go. Period. They're all a joke.

mrducks
59
Points
mrducks 02/18/12 - 06:20 pm
0
0
Joe Bowles likes to act like
Unpublished

Joe Bowles likes to act like he's above the fray, but he's as big a moron as the rest of them.

Insider Information
4009
Points
Insider Information 02/18/12 - 09:29 pm
0
0
The fact that Abie Ladson

The fact that Abie Ladson refused to release any information about how his department is structured is quite revealing.

In essence, he refused to say who works for him, how much his employees are paid, or even the titles of those in his department.

So, we pay his salary and the salary of everyone beneath him, but he wants to operate in secret. Does he think he oversees the CIA or FBI? Somebody needs to come back to reality.

One word: Ridiculous.

corgimom
36711
Points
corgimom 02/19/12 - 07:40 am
0
0
"The lone employee left in

"The lone employee left in transit received a 53 percent pay increase."

WOW!!! What does that person do, anyway?

my.voice
5085
Points
my.voice 02/19/12 - 11:23 am
0
0
Perhaps Mr Ladsons paycheck

Perhaps Mr Ladsons paycheck needs to be held until he complies with the law. I find that there is no structure, list, or other organizational information not credible. If employees are being paid, then then there is the structure. Seems to me that this sort of information should not be solely in the hands of a lone director in any department.

Lori Davis
968
Points
Lori Davis 02/19/12 - 03:09 pm
0
0
Get rid of the liaison guy

Get rid of the liaison guy making $171.00 an hour. Now that is a start.

Craig Spinks
817
Points
Craig Spinks 02/20/12 - 12:49 am
0
0
External personnel audit,

External personnel audit, anyone?

404Law
226
Points
404Law 02/20/12 - 09:36 am
0
0
Chickens coming home to

Chickens coming home to roost?

Little Lamb
47956
Points
Little Lamb 02/20/12 - 10:00 am
0
0
From the article: “I’m hoping

From the article:

“I’m hoping if we get this efficiency study done it will tell us what’s going on,” Commissioner Bill Lockett said. “Someone with the professional expertise (can) come in and give this government an unbiased look, without any internal influences.”

Commissioner Lockett gets it wrong again. The first thing these consultants do when the come into an organization is to check out the lay of the land — the cliques, the "ins" and the "outs," the powerbrokers and the hangers-on, the agendas and who champions the agendas. "Internal influences," as Lockett calls them, are part and parcel of the consulting business.

As Exhibit A I will introduce that worthless study by the Shields organization we paid $500,000 for last year. What kind of efficiency was that?

Little Lamb
47956
Points
Little Lamb 02/20/12 - 10:04 am
0
0
Sandy Hodson and Susan McCord

Sandy Hodson and Susan McCord wrote:

While other area cities and counties responded quickly to open records requests for employee position and salary data, The Augusta Chronicle had to piece together human resources records from the City of Augusta with individual department organizational charts to get an accurate picture of its staffing. In many instances, employees were classified as working in departments that no longer exist.

This is the kind of attention to detail that we have come to expect from Fred (What, me worry?) Russell.

Back to Top

Search Augusta jobs