Government SPLOST 7 | | | Editor

Augusta paid $1.7M to outside law firms in 2011

Former commissioners, city attorney among recipients

Sunday, Jan. 8, 2012 9:35 PM
Last updated Monday, Jan. 9, 2012 12:44 AM
  • Follow Government

Augusta paid about $1.7 million to outside law firms for legal work last year, despite having an in-house legal staff of five full-time attorneys.

A look at records of city payments to law firms shows that $718,000 of the $1.7 million came directly from Augusta’s general fund, with the rest of the legal bills paid using sales-tax or enterprise-fund dollars.

General Counsel Andrew MacKenzie said he’s implemented preventative measures to cut legal costs, such as evaluating cases early and increasing the number of staff attorneys to six, but that the savings can take time to be realized.

Budget documents show the city spent $1.72 million on outside legal counsel during 2010 and budgeted $822,900 for it during 2011.

The biggest recipient of city outside legal spending last year was Shepard, Plunkett and Hamilton, an Augusta law firm that includes Steve Shepard, a former Augusta commissioner and city attorney.

The city paid Shepard, Plunkett and Hamilton $577,538, including $284,133 in general fund dollars and $80,958 in sales-tax money, for legal work last year, records show.

The firm also was paid $174,096 for land acquisition in the Laney-Walker and Bethlehem districts, although a portion of that payment may include the price of land purchased in the blighted area now being redeveloped by the city’s Housing and Community Development Department.

The firm’s Dan Hamilton is handling the city’s defense in a lawsuit over the 2006 fire deaths of Ryan Holt and Michelle Borror. The young couple perished in a mobile home fire their families say could have been prevented if a city inspector had done his job.

The sheer size of the action - 50 depositions have been conducted - would make it difficult for in-house lawyers to focus on anything else if the city hadn’t retained outside counsel, MacKenzie said.

The firm’s Jim Plunkett specializes in economic development legal work, such as the public-private partnerships between Augusta and operators of the Trade, Exhibit and Event Center and the Laney-Walker and Bethlehem redevelopment project, he said.

“These are projects that have been around a long time,” MacKenzie said. “With a long-term project, it’s usually efficient to keep the same legal counsel involved.”

Another big recipient of outside legal work is the law firm Burnside Wall LLP, which includes former city attorney Jim Wall.

Burnside Wall, paid $65,000 from the general fund for legal work last year, handles most legal work for the Richmond County Sheriff’s Office and helped with a suit filed last year by contractor John Speer concerning the city’s award of a construction contract.

McKenna Long & Aldridge, a large international firm, received $289,000 in Augusta general fund dollars during 2011. The firm oversaw creation of Augusta’s tax allocation districts, several recent bond issues and was involved in the Thomson litigation over the city’s use of race-based criteria in the award of city contracts.

McKenna Long & Aldridge does the type of specialized work Augusta will likely always rely on outside counsel to handle, according to MacKenzie.

While the city law office has six lawyer positions, only five are filled. MacKenzie earns $133,992, senior staff attorney Wayne Brown makes $112,506 and staff attorneys Scott Bray, Kayla Cooper and Jody Smitherman earn between $78,000 and $89,000 annually. Their annual insurance, pension, retirement and other benefits, including MacKenzie’s $7,200 annual car allowance, together total approximately $150,000.

An in-house law office was specified by Augusta’s consolidation bill, although it took the commission until 2006 to hire General Counsel Eugene Jessup. Jessup and his successor, Chiquita Johnson, were forced to resign. MacKenzie has been with the office since 2007.

Comments (8) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
jackrussell 01/09/12 - 01:03 am
Why is Richmond county paying

Why is Richmond county paying in-house counsel if they are outsourcing their legal needs? What are the In-house attorneys doing? Seems like all the outsourcing was explained. Please explain what we are paying the others to do. And as for the outside attorneys, seems like they are getting business as a result of the good ol boy kick-back system. What the devil are our commissioners and city administrator thinking? Just think how well we could take care of our county employees, especially police, with the million plus dollars we're shelling out to attorneys for work that should be done by the ones who work for the county. As as far as not having the manpower, how many legal aids, assistants, etc. are we employing to help our county attorneys? This whole things reeks wrongdoing and waste.

Asitisinaug 01/09/12 - 02:51 am
Seems extremely high to me to

Seems extremely high to me to spend close to 2.5 million in legal fees per year for our county when you combine outside law firms with our legal staff.

Augusta Chronicle, compared to other counties, what % of our budget is spent on legal fees compared to their budgets and/or what is spent based on population. Are we in line with others?

nnaugusta 01/09/12 - 03:19 am
Sure will be glad when my Son

Sure will be glad when my Son gets out of law school. Hopefully with his grades and personality he'll land one of these great pay day jobs! Don't take too many cases like these to put you on easy street!

Riverman1 01/09/12 - 05:26 am
Compare with the legal

Compare with the legal expenses of Columbia County.

TrulyWorried 01/09/12 - 08:03 am
jackrussell - no truer words

jackrussell - no truer words were ever spoken!

Craig Spinks
Craig Spinks 01/09/12 - 10:49 am
Another immodest proposal:

Another immodest proposal: Total the compensation paid to employees in the A-RC Law Department, the legal fees A-RC pays to outside law firms, the legal fees paid by each of the various legal entities bearing RC in its name(to include the $608K paid by the RCBOE to the Fletcher firm in FY10), and various and sundry other money paid to lawyers and law firms. How far "north" of $3M would the number be?

raul 01/09/12 - 01:34 pm
They have paid over 500K

They have paid over 500K defending the city on the mobile home deaths which IMO they should have settled. Wait till the city gets the bill when a jury trial rules in favor of the plantiff for a few million dollars.

double_standard 01/09/12 - 01:52 pm
Once again the chronicle and

Once again the chronicle and many of you failed to realize that Bill Lockett was correct in his motion of No Confidence in our county attorney. You people claimed he was grandstanding. Like it or not he's just as incompetent as the one before him. But she wasn't your kind so I guess we won't here any complaining on this one.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
Italy earthquake kills dozens
A strong earthquake in central Italy reduced three towns to rubble as people slept early Wednesday, with reports that as many as 50 people were killed and hundreds injured as rescue crews raced to ...