Crime & Courts Richmond Co. | Columbia Co. | Aiken Co. |

Local judge asks Georgia Supreme Court to end delays in capital murder cases

Wednesday, Feb. 19, 2014 8:00 PM
Last updated 9:43 PM
  • Follow Crime & courts

The judge assigned to preside over a near 5-year-old death penalty case in Augusta has asked the Georgia Supreme Court to do something to end the inordinate delays and ineffectiveness of the capital defender office.

Judge J. David Roper made the plea to the state’s highest court in his mandatory pre-trial report filed Monday in the case of Kelvin Johnson.

Johnson, 29, has pleaded not guilty to charges filed in the Aug. 26, 2009, slaying of 69-year-old Martha Greene and the wounding of her husband, Tilman “T.C.” Greene, during a robbery of their Plantation Road home.

Richmond County sheriff investigators arrested Johnson the day after the attack, a grand jury returned an indictment the following month and the prosecutor filed notice of seeking the death penalty Oct. 30, 2009.

Roper noted in 2012 the two attorneys appointed by the Georgia Capital Defender office to represent Johnson “were not remotely ready for trial.”

Roper then ordered the Georgia Public Defender Standards Council to appear in court to explain why he shouldn’t rule that there was a systemic breakdown in the defense of capital murder cases. The organization responded by appointing two local attorneys to his defense team.

Two more years dragged by before Johnson’s case reached the point the Supreme Court would be asked to determine if one of Roper’s rulings is correct. Once that is decided, Johnson’s case should be ready for trial.

Roper blamed himself for the delay in getting the issue – whether he was correct to allow evidence at trial that DNA tied Johnson to two unrelated burglaries and a rape – to the Supreme Court since Oct. 4.

However, the current system for the defense of capital murder suspects is horrendous, the judge wrote.

“The present capital defender system is denying defendants their right to effective counsel and speedy trial. Trial judges and appellate courts strain to find that delays of four or five years or more are not prejudicial, when in fact they are, to avoid setting a guilty person free,” Roper wrote.

“The public and victims are, likewise, prejudiced because the death penalty system is fraught with frequent and lengthy delays and seemingly endless appeals, undermining confidence in the judicial system. A pool of attorneys defending only capital cases is simply not practicable, efficient or workable.”

The judge cited case law stating the Supreme Court has the power to protect the judiciary and ensure the court system is capable of administering justice in an orderly and efficient manner. Roper asks the court to exercise that power or promulgating rules to ensure justice is served for all participants and the public.

Comments (1) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
nocnoc 02/20/14 - 09:12 am
My personal opinion

My personal opinion is any PD working Murder case, should only be working just 1 case at a time to insure the client gets the best defense and the trial can happen closer to the time of the murder, for justice and freshness to testimony.

But this length of delay borders on deliberate.

FOIA the Evidence release dates to and from each side.
Since both sides have the same access to the evidence by law.
Track when they had it and finally shared it.

Let us see see if they have been milking the system for $$$$. An if they have, charge them with billing fraud and violating the civil rights of the accused. (The right to a speedy trial)

jimmymac 02/21/14 - 04:04 pm

Justice delayed is justice denied. Lawyers milk the system and keep vermin from getting what they have coming to them. There should be a speedy trial and swift justice if convicted. Our current system is a joke and only cares about the rights of the criminals and forgets the victims.

rmwhitley 02/21/14 - 07:01 pm
johnson needs

to be released to the custody of his defense lowyers, housed by them, taken everywhere they go and they (defense team) should be responsible (financially and freedomwise) until a verdict is handed down.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs