In an order filed Friday, U.S. Magistrate Court Judge W. Leon Barfield said there was no way to protect the community or prevent obstruction of justice unless Angela Willingham and Matthew Harrington were denied bond.
They are among 12 defendants named in a 145-count federal indictment. All of the defendants – who include Harrington’s children, sisters and a nephew – have pleaded not guilty to conspiracy, tax fraud and aggravated identity theft.
According to court records and earlier hearings in federal court in Augusta, Willingham is accused of leading a scheme that stole about $1.3 million by filing false income tax returns for people whose identities were stolen.
Willingham’s sisters, Janice Smalley and Patrice Roberson, are accused of using their positions at Georgia Regents Medical Center and the Gracewood State Hospital campus in Augusta to steal patients’ personal information.
According to the indictment, the information was funneled to Willingham and used to create phony income tax return forms that claimed Georgia Lottery winnings and large tax withholding from them.
The tax return checks were deposited into bank accounts opened by the defendants, the indictment says.
Willingham and the others continued the scheme even after it became obvious federal agents were investigating them, the judge wrote.
Willingham and Harrington are accused of destroying evidence, and Willingham is accused of trying to obstruct the investigation by encouraging a co-defendant to lie to investigators.
According to Barfield’s order, even after all the defendants were warned in court and by pretrial services officers that they could not contact each other, Smalley visited Willingham and Harrington in jail. Willingham’s ex-husband, Bryan Gustave, also visited Harrington in violation of his probation officer’s instructions. Gustave and Willingham were convicted in a drug conspiracy in 1998.
The judge wrote that he “must conclude that neither Angela Willingham nor Matthew Harrington are amendable to the traditional judicial restraints placed on the conduct of those accused and convicted of crime.”
A trial date has not been set.