Defense witness rebuts fatal shaking allegations

Wednesday, Aug 15, 2012 7:25 PM
Last updated 10:15 PM
  • Follow Crime & courts

Corduray Scott talks with his attorney, David Aylor, during his trial Wednesday. Scott is accused of inflicting fatal injuries on his 3-month-old son.  ZACH BOYDEN-HOLMES/STAFF
Corduray Scott talks with his attorney, David Aylor, during his trial Wednesday. Scott is accused of inflicting fatal injuries on his 3-month-old son.

Jurors were presented a scientific explanation Wednesday for the severe head trauma that killed a 3-month-old baby in January 2010.

The testimony of Dr. Edward Willey was a rebuttal to allegations that Corduray Scott fatally shook and squeezed Corduray Scott Jr.

Scott is standing trial on charges of felony murder and malice murder and four counts of cruelty to children.

Willey was the first witness for the defense after jurors watched a video of Scott demonstrating with a doll how he jumped around with his child in his arms. They also heard from doctors and a pathologist who said there was no doubt the child’s death was the result of severe head trauma.

The St. Petersburg, Fla., doctor testified that the bleeding in the brain could have been the result of other things besides trauma.

He also suggested that the bleeding behind the eyes – which other doctors said was the result of severe acceleration and deceleration – was a “plumbing issue” and the result of blood pooling in the head.

The nine broken ribs were the result of the child’s bone density issues, not trauma, he said.

Because the child’s broken bones were the result of rickets, it would not have caused him enough pain to make him a fussy child, Willey testified.

Assistant District Attorney Hank Syms anticipated much of the testimony based on Willey’s report and addressed it in his questioning of the doctors who treated the victim and of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation pathologist. Those three witnesses contradicted Willey’s testimony, saying the only possibilities for injuries of that extent were abuse or a car accident.

Testimony has shown that Scott was left alone with his son for several hours early Jan. 18. When the baby’s mother picked him up that morning, Corduray Jr. began having seizures.

Dr. Lora Darrisaw, the deputy chief medical examiner for the GBI, said based on the severity of the infant’s brain injuries, seizures would occur very soon after the injury was inflicted.

Comments (6) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
harley_52 08/15/12 - 08:50 pm
Further Evidence.....

....that for the right price, an "expert" can be on your side too.

daviddunagan 08/15/12 - 08:54 pm
Sad society

It's sad and amazing what people will say and do for money.

communistwookie 08/15/12 - 11:23 pm
Oh my bad

I forgot everyone on augusta chronicle is a lawyer and expert on everything everything. Such condensending comments for people that were not there and are not medical experts...

Tullie 08/16/12 - 05:51 am

How in the world could this 3-month old child have had rickets? This is not a third world country where mothers and babies do not have access to medical care.

realitycheck09 08/16/12 - 12:34 pm
To be clear...

...Apparently I'm to assume (based on harley and DD's comments above) that the state's experts - who are paid and/or employed by law enforcement agencies - are telling the truth, are unbiased and are giving gospel testimony, but the expert hired by the defense is a liar and a quack?

urright 08/16/12 - 05:00 pm

Yes. Yes you are. The guy confessed to squeezing the child, smothering the child, and jumping around with him. That's what we call corroboration in law enforcement circles.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
Hot temps increase worries about children left alone in cars
Despite continual warnings by police and child advocates, the number of children dying in hot cars is already close to surpassing last year with five months left in 2016.