Crime & Courts Richmond Co. | Columbia Co. | Aiken Co. |

3 men sentenced in Columbia County sexual assault case

Friday, Nov. 4, 2011 3:31 PM
Last updated 3:36 PM
  • Follow Crime & courts

Three men on trial for sexually assaulting a teen at a party last fall pleaded guilty to false imprisonment just before a judge was going to declare a mistrial because of a hung jury.

The trial of Jason Scott Turner, 22, of Evans; Robert Lincoln Levy, 21, of Augusta; and Tyler William Davitte, 23, of Martinez, began Monday. The trio is charged with aggravated sexual battery in connection to an assault, which occurred at a home on Shaw Street in Martinez.

The jury began deliberations Wednesday afternoon and were deadlocked as of Friday afternoon. As Superior Court Chief Judge J. Carlisle Overstreet prepared to declare a mistrial, which would set the case for a retrial, each of the men pleaded guilty to false imprisonment.

For the felony, which brings a punishment of up to five years in prison, Overstreet sentenced each man to 365 days in the Columbia County Detention Center followed by four years on probation.

“What has occurred at this thing (party) has put a black mark on this community,” Overstreet told the men after sentencing them. “You all have some time that you’ve got to make back to the community, the people involved in this thing. I seriously hope that you start paying back your community and doing something to build up the community instead of doing something to cast a doubt on it.

“I’m going to make sure that in all those years on probation, that you do something to improve this community, not necessarily put a mark on it.”

Police received information Sept. 20, 2010, about underage drinking, drug activity and sex at a Shaw Street home in Martinez owned by Donald Everett “Trey” Morrison.

The investigation found that in August, an 18-year-old girl was drinking at the home. Her friend passed out on the sofa while she reportedly went into a bedroom with one of the men.

Two others came in and sexually assaulted her, police said. A friend beckoned Clayton Edward Blanton into the room to record video with his phone. He recorded the activities, but before leaving, he woke up the victim’s friend to tell her what was happening in the bedroom.

“There is a slime, an ick-factor that hovers over that house,” Levy’s attorney, Jason Troiano, said during closing arguments Wednesday, telling jurors that a not-guilty verdict would not equate to condoning the behavior at the Shaw Street house. “I think we can all agree on that.”

But the defense attorneys all argued holes in the case including the victim’s lack of memory of the event and poorly documented chain of custody records.

Each man had to issue an apology to the victim and her friend as part of the sentence.

“I’m so sorry,” Turner said at his sentencing. “I’m so sorry that we had to go through this.”

As part of a negotiated plea agreement with the District Attorney’s Office, Blanton, 22, of Evans, pleaded guilty to unlawful surveillance in August. Overstreet sentenced him to 23 months in jail.

Davitte and Turner were taken into custody at the sentencing. Levy, who has already served nearly nine months, gets credit for that time.

Comments (6) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Patty-P 11/04/11 - 04:10 pm
hmmm...trying to do the

hmmm...trying to do the the unlawful surveillance got more time than unlawful imprisonment? (23 months as opposed to 365 days)

Vito45 11/04/11 - 05:43 pm
Does not compute does it?

Does not compute does it?

nancynurse 11/04/11 - 05:47 pm
a travesty of justice if you

a travesty of justice if you ask me. that's disgusting. worst part...'“I’m so sorry,” Turner said at his sentencing. “I’m so sorry that we had to go through this.”' he is not even sorry except for what he has "had to go through"!!!

bclicious 11/04/11 - 06:23 pm
From a strategic point of

From a strategic point of view, they should have held out.

shrimp for breakfast
shrimp for breakfast 11/04/11 - 08:49 pm
Man I bet the guy doing 23

Man I bet the guy doing 23 months is mad as a yellow jacket!
He got double the time and he didn't even sexually assault anyone.
I mean shooting video of it is really low-life but the difference in their sentences makes the whole legal process seem a tad askew.

jmckee226 11/07/11 - 10:28 am
blanton got the shaft. when

blanton got the shaft. when your well known in columbia county there are no plea agreements. blanton will probably be home and on parole way before those boys are released. hell probably only do 15 months or less. also keep in mind he couldnt keep his nose clean and that sentence consisted of other charges as well.

Back to Top
Search Augusta jobs
Top headlines
CME gives Paine $1 million but more needed
The donation, which is "already in the bank," brings to $4.1 million the amount the college has raised this fiscal year and it will end on Thursday with the embattled school having positive "net ...