Survey finds actual fuel cost for new cars

  • Follow Smart Shopper

DETROIT — Every new car window sticker shows the estimated cost of fuel for a year, but that figure might not reflect the miles you drive. A new survey does that math for you.

GasBuddy.com, a Web site that uses data from volunteers, gas stations and other sources to track fuel prices nationwide, ranked more than 750 vehicles from the 2013 model year based on the cost of fuel per mile driven. The survey used the average price in July – $3.59 per gallon – and measured vehicles based on their combined city and highway mileage as calculated by the Environmental Protection Agency.

Honda vehicles performed best, averaging 12.8 cents per mile. Gen­eral Motors Co.’s GMC brand was worst, averaging 21.2 cents.

After Honda, the most efficient brands were Kia, Hyundai, Volks­wagen, Mazda, Subaru, Mitsubishi and Toyota. The worst, after GMC, were Cadillac, Mer­ce­des-Benz, Jeep, Jaguar, Infiniti, Chev­rolet, Dodge, Porsche and Chrysler.

GMC spokesman Brian Goebel pointed out that the brand’s lineup is all trucks and SUVs, and lacks small cars to bring down the average.
He also said the brand is improving. The 2014 GMC Sierra pickup gets up to 20 mpg in combined city and highway driving, up from 17 in the previous model year.

The most efficient car, the Toyota Prius C hybrid subcompact, costs 7.2 cents per mile. The least efficient, a Bugatti Veyron sports car with a 16-cylinder engine, costs 35.9 cents. Assuming you drive 12,000 miles per year, the Prius C would cost you $864 to fill up; the Veyron would cost $4,308. But anyone who buys the $1.3 million Veyron probably isn’t worried about fuel cost.

Hybrids generally did well, but beware: You pay a premium up front, and it takes years to recoup that cost in fuel savings.

The regular Ford Fusion midsize sedan costs 12.8 cents per mile, while the hybrid version costs 7.6 cents. Assuming you drive 15,000 miles per year, the regular Fusion costs $1,920 to fill up, while the hybrid costs $1,140, a difference of $780 per year. But the hybrid costs $5,300 more than the base model. You’d need to drive the hybrid for nearly seven years to break even.

Tom Kloza, an analyst with GasBuddy, said he wasn’t surprised by the rankings. But he was impressed by the number of vehicles in the 12- to 15-cent range. That’s where you’ll find the Toyota Camry midsize car, Ford Escape SUV, Mazda5 minivan and even the Porsche Boxster sports car.

“You don’t have to be Wayne and Garth driving around in a little Pacer to get a reasonable bang for your buck,” he said.

Starting with the 2013 model year, every new car’s window sticker must show the EPA’s estimated annual fuel costs. But those costs assume that the owner will drive 15,000 miles per year and pay $3.70 per gallon. That will vary by driver, and where they buy gas. Right now, for example, drivers in South Carolina are paying $3.24 per gallon while those in Hawaii are paying $4.33.

Whatever you pay, and whatever you drive, the EPA has some suggestions for saving money. Speeding, and rapid acceleration and braking, can lower your gas mileage by 33 percent at highway speeds, or by 5 percent in city driving. Use cruise control on the highway to maintain a constant speed. And when you stop, turn off the engine, since idling wastes fuel.

WHAT THE SURVEY SAYS

Here were the individual models with the best and worst fuel economy, and the gas cost per mile:

TEN BEST:

1. Toyota Prius C, 7.2 cents

2. Toyota Prius, 7.2 cents

3.Toyota Prius plug-in hybrid, 7.3 cents

4. Ford Fusion hybrid, 7.6 cents

5. Ford C-Max hybrid, 7.6 cents

6. Lincoln MKZ hybrid, 8.0 cents

7. Volkswagen Jetta hybrid, 8.0 cents

8. Honda Civic hybrid, 8.2 cents

9. Ford Fusion Energi plug-in hybrid, 8.3 cents

10. Ford C-Max Energi plug-in hybrid, 8.3 cents

Best non-hybrid: Scion iQ, 9.7 cents

Best non-hybrid mid-size car: Volkswagen Passat, 10.6 cents

TEN WORST:

1.Bugatti Veyron, 35.9 cents

2. Ford E350 wagon, 32.6 cents

3. Lamborghini Aventador, 29.9 cents

4.Chevrolet Suburban 2500 (two-wheel drive), 29.9 cents

5. GMC Yukon XL 2500 (two-wheel drive), 29.9 cents

6. Ford E350 cargo van, 29.9 cents

7. GMC Savanna cargo van, 29.9 cents

8. Chevrolet Express 2500 cargo van, 29.9 cents

9. Chevrolet Suburban 2500 (four-wheel drive), 29.9 cents

10. GMC Yukon XL 2500 (four-wheel drive) , 29.9 cents

Worst pickup: Ford F150 (four-wheel drive, V8 engine), 22.4 cents


Top headlines

UGA seeks Gurley reinstatement

ATHENS, Ga. -- Georgia will file paperwork today with the NCAA to seek reinstatement for suspended star running back Todd Gurley, the school said in an announcement Wednesday morning.
Search Augusta jobs