Sears Holdings Corp.’s shares plummeted in after-hours trading Thursday after the beleaguered retailer said it expects a hefty loss for the fourth quarter and full year as sales during the holiday season dropped sharply.
The retailer, which operates Sears and Kmart stores, said that it expects an adjusted loss between $213 million and $316 million, or $2.01 to $2.98 per share, for its fourth quarter. For the year, it forecast an adjusted loss between $811 million and $914 million, or $7.64 to $8.61 per share.
Two analysts surveyed by FactSet had expected a profit of 38 cents per share for the fourth quarter and a loss of $6.80 for the year, on average.
The retailer, based in Hoffman Estates, Ill., also said its Kmart and Sears chains combined had a 7.4 percent drop in revenue from stores open at least a year for the nine-week period ended Jan. 6. For Sears Canada, that figure was down 4.4 percent. This decline in a key measure, which strips away the impact of recently opened or closed stores, was sharper than in the third quarter.
The dismal results raise more questions about the retailer’s future. It also underscores the heavy pressure that Eddie Lampert, hedge fund billionaire and Sears’ chairman and CEO, faces to turn around the business. Lampert engineered the combination of Sears and Kmart in 2005, about two years after he helped bring Kmart out of bankruptcy.
To improve its business, Sears is shifting away from its focus on running a store network into a business that is members-focused, where its most loyal shoppers receive incentives to buy. The company once again blamed that transition for weighing on results as it continues to do traditional promotions while investing in its membership loyalty program called Shop Your Way. But it said it was confident it would work in the long run.
At the same, time, Sears has been trying to restore profitability by cutting costs, reducing inventory and selling off some assets and spinning off others. Last month, Sears announced it will spin off its Lands’ End clothing business as a separate company by distributing stock to the retailer’s shareholders.
“The results that we posted are not nearly what we want them to be,” said Lampert in a blog that he posted on the company Web site. “They also overshadow all of the work that’s being done by our associates, our vendors and the other businesses we work with, along with everyone who is developing better ways for us to serve our members.”
Sears said that Shop Your Way members accounted for 69 percent of its sales in the nine-week period ended Jan. 4, up from 58 percent in the year ago period.
Analysts, however, said that the latest results show shoppers are not buying the membership strategies.
“Clearly, he is fully committed to the (membership strategy), but it’s clear that it has not gained enough momentum to make up for the losses that are happening,” said David Tawil, the co-founder and portfolio manager of Maglan Capital, which follows distressed companies.
In particularly, Tawil noted that Sears’ earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization – an approximate measure of a company’s operating cash flow – in the critical fourth quarter was particularly disturbing.
Sears said that it expects what’s known as EBITDA would be anywhere between a loss of $80 million and a gain of $20 million. That compares with a gain of $365 million for last year’s fourth quarter.
By division, Kmart had a 5.7 percent drop, while Sears stores in the U.S. suffered a 9.2 percent drop for the quarter to date.
The company said it expects to release final results for the fourth quarter and full year in late February.
Sears Holding Corp. shares fell 13 percent, or $5.77, to $36.80 in after-hours trading after closing down more than 3 percent, or $1.40 to $42.57 in regular trading.