The eighth-grader from Garfield, N.J., started an online petition asking Pawtucket, R.I.-based Hasbro to make the toy ovens in gender-neutral colors and feature boys on the package.
In a week, 13-year-old McKenna Pope’s petition garnered more than 30,000 signatures.
“Obviously, the way they’re marketing this product is influencing what he thinks and the way that he acts,” McKenna said.
A Hasbro spokesman did not return calls for comment.
In a letter McKenna received Monday, a Hasbro representative said the company has had boys on the packaging over the years and said a brother and sister were finalists for the Easy-Bake “Baker of the Year” award in 2009.
McKenna found the response disappointing.
“All they really told me is that boys play with their products. I already know boys do play with your products, so why are you only marketing them to girls?” she said. “I don’t want them to make a boys’ Easy-Bake Oven and girls’ Easy-Bake Oven. I want them to make an Easy-Bake Oven for kids.”
The debate over whether toys reinforce gender stereotypes – pinks and princesses for girls, guns and gross things for boys – seems to flare every year and has involved Legos, toy microscopes and Barbie dolls.
Celebrity chef Flay, 47, said he asked for an Easy-Bake for Christmas when he was about 5. At the time, he said, the stereotype was that only women cooked, but a lot has changed since then.
“I cannot tell you how many young boys are my fans. And they want to grow up, and they want to cook,” the Food Network chef said.
Jim Silver, a toy expert and editor in chief of Timetoplaymag.com, played with an Easy-Bake himself as a kid and said boys still play with it, just as girls play with Hot Wheels cars. He said Hasbro is simply marketing to the audience most likely to buy the oven and there’s nothing wrong with that.
About seven years ago, Hasbro had a cooking product aimed at boys, the Queasy Bake Cookerator, which included recipes for gross-sounding treats such as Dip n’ Drool Dog Bones and Mud n’ Crud Cake. “Sales failed miserably,” Silver said.
Flay said he is not surprised it failed because Hasbro was trying to appeal to boys in a stereotypical way. Instead, he urged the toymaker to think about widening the market for the Easy-Bake.
“Why not actually create something that everybody knows the name, but also it comes in different colors so that boys, girls, doesn’t matter, they can pick what color they want and it will make them a little more comfortable to buy it?” he said.
In the meantime, he said, Gavyn’s family should buy him an Easy-Bake Oven anyway.
“Absolutely. If that’s what he wants, why not get it for him? I mean, who cares what color it is?” he said.