Letter grades not included in test of SC teacher evaluation system

Plan for teacher evaluations will be tested in SC

  • Follow News

COLUMBIA — A performance-based teacher evaluation system being tested this year across South Carolina won’t include letter grades, a deputy superintendent said Monday.

So far, 47 schools in 14 districts have signed on to help finalize Superintendent Mick Zais’ proposal for evaluating educators. Several more are expected to be added before classes start next month.

One of the most controversial aspects of the plan has been dropped from the 2013-14 testing period. Teachers will not receive an A through F letter grade on their evaluation.

Zais had advocated the idea as a way to clearly communicate to teachers how they’re performing. But educators opposed it as degrading, and the state Board of Education sided with them. While a pilot project doesn’t need board approval, a statewide model will, and board leaders made clear at a meeting last November they did not like that provision.

Deputy Superintendent Charmeka Childs said the agency’s focus this year needs to be on developing how teachers are evaluated, not a grade only they would see.

“We are listening,” she said. “This was definitely
an area we received feedback.”

She added, however, that grades could still be part of Zais’ proposal next summer for a statewide evaluation system.

The director of the Palmetto State Teachers Association Kathy Maness said she’s proud that teachers voiced their concerns and is glad officials listened.

“We’ve said from the beginning that’s not a good way to evaluate teachers,” Maness said.

Evaluating educators based on performance is a required part of the state’s exemption from the all-or-nothing provisions of the federal No Child Left Behind law. States that granted the waivers are exempt from requirements that all students score proficient on state-standardized math and reading tests by 2014.

The U.S. Education Department approved South Carolina’s request for flexibility in July. Earlier this year, it OK’d the state’s specific plan for evaluations, disappointing educator groups that had offered their own plan.

Zais’ plan was preliminarily tested in 22 schools last school year that needed to implement some form of performance-based evaluations to fulfill requirements for federal grants. Zais wanted at least eight districts to volunteer for 2013-14. He pushed the idea to superintendents as the best way for them to get involved in the decision-making process.

Education advocates, who blasted the agency’s plan as invalid and unreliable, expected getting volunteers to be difficult.

Childs said officials are pleased by the participation. Of the 47 schools signed on so far, 14 are school improvement grant recipients, she said.

“It speaks to the recognition that this is an important decision the state is making in how we want to shape the future of our evaluation system,” she said.


Top headlines

Georgia Regents' hospital plan chosen

Georgia Regents Medical Center won a lengthy and hardfought battle over two other Augusta hospitals to build the first hospital in Columbia County, the Georgia Department of Community Health ...
Search Augusta jobs