In its unanimous decision Wednesday, the state Supreme Court wrote that, even if defense attorneys thought their client’s testimony might harm their case, a trial judge should have allowed Raymondeze Rivera, 34, to speak on his own behalf.
“The circumstances of this case are particularly disturbing,” the court wrote. “Appellant’s testimony may have been prejudicial to his case but that cannot serve as a basis for the trial court to prevent him from taking the stand.”
Rivera has been on death row since his 2010 conviction in the strangling of Kwana Burns. The 28-year-old mother’s body was discovered in her Anderson home in December 2006, bound with her 9-year-old son’s jump rope. Her 2-year-old daughter was discovered asleep near her, unharmed.
Rivera, who is originally from Sarasota, Fla., is also serving a life sentence for the death of another young Anderson mother killed two days before Burns. Authorities have said Rivera confessed to tying up and suffocating 27-year-old Asha Wiley after she begged for her life.
At his trial in Wiley’s death, Rivera testified that he had gone to Anderson to kill Burns, and then killed Wiley because she knew too much.
In its opinion, the Supreme Court cited lengthy passages from Rivera’s trial in Burns’ death, including conversations he had with the trial judge about his right to testify on his own behalf.
The judge went on to say that, while Rivera had the right to testify, he wouldn’t allow it because the defendant refused to give specifics on what he planned to say on the stand.
The court’s decision overturns both Rivera’s conviction and death sentence in Burns’ death, and no new trial date has been set.