Online commentary by the Augusta Chronicle Editorial Staff

Made in America? Well ...

Budding free-market economists say the darndest things!

 

After going through a fast-food drive-through recently, my 6-year-old daughter started tearing apart her kid's meal with wolverine-like ferocity to get to the toy inside.

 

It was a cute blonde doll, which typically would've spurred a little squeal of delight from my little girl. Instead, I kid you not, I got this question after she scrutinized the packaging:

 

"Why are all the Madame Alexander dolls made in China!?"

 

Interesting question. Smarter people have been asking variations of that same question for years now.

 

The long answer is complicated. The short answer? America just doesn't make stuff anymore.

 

Start with your clothes. Take 'em off and check the labels on what you're wearing, and see how much stuff has been manufactured overseas. However, you shouldn't do that in your cubicle at work. Don't ask me how I know this.

 

Some of the most iconic, quintessentially American consumer products aren't so American anymore.

 

Did you ever have a Radio Flyer red wagon when you were a kid? They used to make them in Chicago. But they got too expensive to make. So in 2004, the company cut 45 jobs and moved production to China.

 

Levi's jeans used to be a proud American-made product, symbolic of America itself. But a pair hasn't been made here since 2003. Now they're sewn at factories in Latin America and Asia.

 

What's more American than baseball? The balls officially used by major League Baseball are made by Rawlings - and stitched in Costa Rica.

 

Oh, and NBA uniforms? Adidas used to make them in America, but in 2009 it cut short a contract and moved production to Thailand.

 

Now I know you used to have an Etch-a-Sketch. Fun toy. It's made by a company called Ohio Art. How American-sounding can you get, right? Well, that company wanted cheap, nonunion labor, so in 2000, after 40 years in business, it moved production to - wait for it - China.

 

And if you thought my daughter was quizzical about her little Madame Alexander doll being made in China, imagine how her mind would be blown if I told her that her Barbie dolls were made over there, too.

 

And even if something is technically "made in America," it could be composed of a gazillion parts from other countries. Government data about our Gross Domestic Product is chilling: In 2009, about 60 percent of the value of goods sold in America was imported. In 1980 it was 14 percent. In 1960, 8 percent.

 

The Federal Trade Commission has 40 pages of regulations that companies have to follow if they want to claim their products are "made in America." They're not always "made," either. Sometimes products are merely "produced," "created," "assembled" or "designed" in America. Tod Marks, a senior editor at Consumer Reports, says five federal agencies help hash out the $64,000 manufacturing question "What does 'America' really mean?"

 

What does it mean? These days, not as much as it used to, especially with China beating our brains out when it comes to manufacturing.

 

Kevin Kearns, president of the U.S. Business and Industry Council, pointed out to IndustryWeek how China "has consistently manipulated its currency to steal productive capacity from the United States." That allows China to "devastate America's invaluable productive industries, addict the country to debt-fueled, bubble-created 'growth' and destabilize the global economy."

 

Maybe I could've said all or part of this to my daughter on the drive home from the restaurant, but I held my tongue. Talking about America's crumbling manufacturing base with a 6-year-old on a Sunday afternoon just would've been too depressing.

 

Maybe I can try something else. Did Milton Friedman write any Fisher-Price board books? Where can I find a colorful pop-up version of Atlas Shrugged?

    • Syndicate content

Comments (20)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
omnomnom
193
Points
omnomnom 09/15/10 - 05:32 pm
0
0

make it a game. see if you

make it a game. see if you can find anything made in america at the dollar store. is you find it, buy it, that way everybody wins. unless you don't need cheap cardboard decor that'll fall apart. or beef jerky.

gaspringwater
3
Points
gaspringwater 09/15/10 - 06:00 pm
0
0

Excuse me Ms. Hotchkiss, we

Excuse me Ms. Hotchkiss, we still manufacture a wide array of weaponry in America. And making hardware to kill people is an American forte, par excellence.

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/15/10 - 08:42 pm
0
0

"Ms."?

"Ms."?

flipa
0
Points
flipa 09/15/10 - 09:38 pm
0
0

Uuh How bought John Deer, THE


Uuh How bought John Deer, THE most treasured Tractor in the ENTIRE WORLD, and the new Ford midengine sports car and the NEW Fiesta the first of which beat every Ferrari around when i was in Rome Italy and the 2 Fiesta's that smoked the Scooby Impreza's in off road racing causing me to come right out of my chair???

Bell Jet Rangers, Gulfstream jets, Harley Davidson, Airstream Travel Trailers, Oreck, about half of the Dodge Rams etc. etc. etc. and that's just right off the top of my head...Love you Joe but we make the BEST stuff on the PLANET just not the CHEAPEST crap, and THAT is cool with U.S.

Watch this Thursday Night at 9 on WBEK and you'll see one of the BEST crime fighting shows in the world featuring up to 5 million dollar rewards. What other country makes that?

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/15/10 - 09:34 pm
0
0

jdxyz can refer to Newsweek:

jdxyz can refer to Newsweek: "After German sports-apparel maker Adidas became the NBA’s official uniform supplier in 2006, the company contracted out the actual production of jerseys, shorts, and the like to American garment manufacturers. But in late 2009 Adidas announced it would cut short a contract that had been set to expire in 2014 and use factories in Thailand instead."

Also, there's this story from Fox News: http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2009/11/24/schumer-blasts-adidas-plan-nb...

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/15/10 - 09:56 pm
0
0

flipa, good points. I drive a

flipa, good points. I drive a Jeep. I've got a Kenmore fridge, washer and dryer, and a Whirlpool dishwasher. All of 'em are American-made and I love 'em.

I also have a Zenith TV. American? Used to be. But in 1985 it moved TV production to Mexico. Today it's a brand of the South Korean conglomerate LG.

Obviously, America still "makes stuff" -- just not on the scale it used to. We need a much, much stronger manufacturing sector.

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/15/10 - 10:07 pm
0
0

Have any corroborating links

Have any corroborating links you can post, jdxyz?

ohhsweetconcord
0
Points
ohhsweetconcord 09/15/10 - 10:10 pm
0
0

Well, producing t-shirt,

Well, producing t-shirt, tennis shoes, and cheap tops isn't going to increase the manufacturing sector. Its really kind of silly to focus on those things. When was the last time you went to the movies? You probably saw a Hollywood blockbuster that was made in America. Used Google recently? That's made in America. Played Halo on the Xbox recently? That was made in America too.

All this focus on physical items is more a product of human psychology that any kind of serious economic focus. We don't want to necessarily want to have Americans making tennis shoes or toys. We want them inventing.

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/15/10 - 10:20 pm
0
0

ohhsweetconcord has a good

ohhsweetconcord has a good point, too (and good taste in Monty Python movies). Ideas as America's No. 1 product? Absolutely. But folks in Flint, Mich., with a 15-plus-percent jobless rate, can't eat ideas or deposit them in their bank accounts. We need more great American inventions and ideas that'll keep and grow jobs stateside.

dwb619
936
Points
dwb619 09/15/10 - 11:54 pm
0
0

Would eliminating the

Would eliminating the corporate income tax bring our smoke-stack industries back? Seems like I read a couple of years back, about Ireland cutting their corporate tax rate, resulting in a huge industrial expansion.

padre.will
0
Points
padre.will 09/16/10 - 10:09 am
0
0

That's not the whole story,

That's not the whole story, though. Yes, Ireland assiduously courted corporations (like Apple, for example, who run their headquarters there instead of the UK), through a variety of tools, including preferential tax rates. But they also had billions and billions and billions of euros poured into their economy by the European Union. I suspect that, if an analogous thing were tried in the States, there'd be cries of bloody murder. (Witness the pasting Obama's taking for continuing Bush's bank-bailout programme.)

maggiemae
0
Points
maggiemae 09/16/10 - 11:24 am
0
0

It appears to me if the

It appears to me if the unions would drop the huge salaries they pay to those in line with non-union workers we could salvage most, or at least a large portion, of our jobs. Do they have to be so greedy? Perhaps rather than union salaries of 80 dollars an hour the worker could live on like maybe 30 dollars an hours like a non-union worker would.

Quack Quack Quack
0
Points
Quack Quack Quack 09/16/10 - 12:23 pm
0
0

Spot-on maggiemae!! In the

Spot-on maggiemae!! In the article, Joe says that the companies want "cheap" non-labor union production. The unions have brought our production to a stand-still. As maggiemae points out 80 dollars is great for the worker, but as she also points out maybe 30 dollars would suffice. I think Americans would pay a little more for products Made In America, by Americans. If the unions would make changes, or if we do away with them altogether, maybe we could become the great producing country we once were.

Quack Quack Quack
0
Points
Quack Quack Quack 09/16/10 - 12:25 pm
0
0

BTW Nice article Joe, just be

BTW Nice article Joe, just be sure that your daughter doesn't chew the paint!!!!

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/16/10 - 01:18 pm
0
0

LOL! Quack Quack Quack, she's

LOL! Quack Quack Quack, she's out of the "get that out of your mouth" stage, and into the "what's coming out of her mouth" stage. Much funnier with her vocabulary.

dwb619
936
Points
dwb619 09/16/10 - 02:13 pm
0
0

As a union member, I will

As a union member, I will tell you the $80 is total BS. This is propoganda at its worst. Total packages run nowhere near that amount. These sound like the cost a contractor charges per man hour.
As a after thought, I know there is someone on this board who can tell me what role the unions played in driving the textile industry off-shore.
I am going RV'ing rest of the week, so all your shots will be un-answered, and I fully expect to attacked on a personal level.

Quack Quack Quack
0
Points
Quack Quack Quack 09/16/10 - 02:16 pm
0
0

Thanks Joe. I know what you

Thanks Joe. I know what you mean. I've long ago passed that time of the stage you refer to. My kids are now adults. I do remember the funny things a 6 year will come-up with. I still get that great feeling from my grandchildren. I'm not LOL, as in how many of our children have been effected by shoddy products from China. We really should do anything to bring back production to this GREAT country to help our economy and for just peace-of-mind. IMO!!!

seenitB4
651
Points
seenitB4 09/17/10 - 07:11 am
0
0

Thank you Mr. Hotchkiss for

Thank you Mr. Hotchkiss for stating what is most obvious to most....try looking at the laundry products & notice how many aren't made here anymore...
The unions need to bend some BUT let's not blame them for everything. Make an effort to buy AMERICAN, our economy depends on it!
I have wondered when AC would print articles like this....even begged them to do this,,,,thanks again :)

seenitB4
651
Points
seenitB4 09/17/10 - 07:14 am
0
0

Also Hotchkiss....I now will

Also Hotchkiss....I now will follow you, just in case you do this again.

Joe Hotchkiss
0
Points
Joe Hotchkiss 09/17/10 - 01:34 pm
0
0

*tips hat to seenitB4* I'll

*tips hat to seenitB4* I'll try to keep the streak alive!

Back to Top
Top headlines

Third flesh-eating bacteria case reported

A Cartersville man is facing his sixth surgery today after contracting the same flesh-decaying bacterial infection as Aimee Copeland.
Online Database by Caspio
Click here to load this Caspio Online Database.

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1467/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1471/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1470/
  • title http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1468/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1465/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1462/
  • title http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1461/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1441/ http://spotted.augusta.com/galleries/1460/
Mayfest 2012
Loading...